Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026
7 1 26 WO PB Draft Minutes
2e4c7c42a270498c0c3576e47d85bc4d985dc27f3a8f765c33c1de4f25d6b446Indexed text
re countywide. He stated that the County had indicated in their conversation that, over the previous five years, there had been over 200 pedestrian hits. - Mr. Malanga asked whether there had been any discussion specifically of pedestrian incidents on Eagle Rock Avenue between Laurel Avenue and the proposed traffic light. Mr. Pehnke stated that there had not. - Mr. Paul Trachtenberg, at 96 Sullivan Drive, followed up on Mr. Malanga's question concerning pedestrian crossings near the proposed traffic signal. Mr. Trachtenberg asked whether Mr. Pehnke or anyone else had conducted a count of how many pedestrians try to cross that area. Mr. Pehnke stated that they had not specifically conducted a pedestrian count. Based on observation, he said he would suspect that pedestrian activity was relatively light. - Mr. Trachtenberg asked whether Mr. Pehnke had conducted any study of how many pedestrians walk up and down Eagle Rock Avenue in the vicinity of the traffic signal. Mr. Pehnke stated that he had not. - Mr. Trachtenberg asked whether the turning numbers and other indicators used in the analysis had taken into account traffic proposed by the West Essex Highlands development. Mr. Pehnke stated that the design considered both existing traffic at the intersection and increased traffic. He specifically stated that the design was intended to
8 accommodate increased traffic, including traffic from the West Essex Highlands project should that project advance. - Mr. Trachtenberg noted that the Planning Board had denied the West Essex Highlands application and that it appeared that there would be no additional traffic from that development in the near future. He asked whether that affected Mr. Pehnke's analysis. Mr. Pehnke stated that it did not. - Mr. Trachtenberg asked whether, in Mr. Pehnke's judgment, the traffic signal was required whether or not the additional development occurred. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that it was. - Mr. Trachtenberg asked Mr. Pehnke to elaborate on his earlier statement that the signal at Laurel Avenue and Eagle Rock Avenue could communicate with the proposed new signal. Mr. Pehnke explained that, when traffic signals are located along an arterial corridor, the goal is to coordinate them. He explained that this is currently done by installing GPS units, essentially clocks, that tie into satellites so that all signals or controllers operate at the exact same time. Mr. Pehnke stated that, once the signals are synchronized, their operations can be coordinated to maintain progressive flow along Eagle Rock Avenue. - Mr. Trachtenberg asked about his understanding that there was an engineering principle or traffic signal rule requiring signals to be at least 1,000 feet apart and asked whether he was stating that accurately. Mr. Pehnke stated that this was incorrect. Mr. Pehnke explained that traffic signals can be as close as a couple hundred feet apart and that there are examples of this throughout the area. - Mr. Tractenberg asked whether, in Karl Pehnke’s professional opinion, having two traffic signals on Eagle Rock Avenue within approximately 800–820 feet would be an issue. Mr. Pehnke responded that it would not be an issue. He stated that the additional signal would improve traffic flow and safety in the area. - Mr. Tractenberg asked whether, in Mr. Pehnke’s professional opinion, the major reason for signalizing the intersection is public safety rather than the convenience of the Country Club and its members. Mr. Pehnke responded that there are a multitude of reasons. - Seth Weisleder, at 17 Howe Drive, asked what current operational problems exist with the existing driveway. Mr. Pehnke referred to his testimony from the previous meeting and explained that the existing
th Weisleder, at 17 Howe Drive, asked what current operational problems exist with the existing driveway. Mr. Pehnke referred to his testimony from the previous meeting and explained that the existing driveway: ○ Comes down onto Eagle Rock Avenue at an acute angle. ○ Has a final section that is relatively steep, approximately 7–8%, as it approaches Eagle Rock Avenue. ○ Enters Eagle Rock Avenue just to the west side of a bend in the road. ○ Has restricted sight lines due to existing tree lines and vegetation. ○ Makes it difficult for drivers to look left and back up Eagle Rock Avenue because of the acute angle. - Mr. Weisleder asked how many crashes had occurred at the current driveway during the previous five years and whether this had been evaluated. Mr. Pehnke stated that he had not done that analysis. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether there was a documented safety problem today, beyond Mr. Pehnke’s testimony. Mr. Pehnke responded that they had not researched or evaluated the location based on particular accident data. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether Essex County had requested that the driveway be moved. Mr. Pehnke explained that several years ago, before his involvement, the issue had arisen in connection with the West Essex Highland application, which is off Oval Road. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether Pehnke’s analysis evaluates the future 2027 build, including the West Essex Highlands development. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that it does.
9 - Mr. Weisleder asked whether, when evaluating the driveway in its existing location, did he evaluate restricting left turns, right-in/right-out access only, and limiting event traffic. Mr. Pehnke answered no. ○ When Mr. Weisleder asked about right-out access, Mr. Pehnke clarified that there is no inbound access at the existing driveway and that it is an egress driveway only. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether internal circulation changes had been evaluated. Mr. Pehnke stated that there are internal circulation changes associated with the application. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether a formal site-distance analysis had been performed with regard to the proposed signal. Mr. Pehnke explained that once the signal is in place, the sight-line issues are obviated. He stated that the sight-line issues are readily apparent when driving through the intersection. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether crest vertical curves were evaluated. Mr. Pehnke stated that site distance is not significantly impacted by vertical curves in this area. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether stopping distances were calculated. Mr. Pehnke responded no, there’s no reason to. - Mr. Weisleder confirmed that the application also proposes 32 additional parking spaces. Mr. Pehnke confirmed this and stated that Mr. Cote would address the issue further. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether, if the application were recommended for the additional 32 parking spaces without additional development in the area, the proposed traffic light would essentially be serving the Country Club. Mr. Pehnke disagreed and stated that the signal also serves Oval Road and controls traffic along Eagle Rock Avenue. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether the number of vehicles associated with the 32 additional parking spaces would warrant a full traffic signal with pedestrian crossings, particularly because the other intersection does not have the same pedestrian crossings. Mr. Pehnke responded that the Country Club itself does not warrant the signal. He stated that Oval Road traffic warrants the signal. - Rachel Klein, at Howell Drive, questioned the repeated references to Essex County wanting or believing the project is needed. She asked whether the county wants the improvement for Crestmont or because of the potential additional traffic from West Essex Highlands. Mr. Pehnke explained that the issue is a funding priority issue. ○ He stated that government
nts the improvement for Crestmont or because of the potential additional traffic from West Essex Highlands. Mr. Pehnke explained that the issue is a funding priority issue. ○ He stated that government entities have restrictions and limited funding available. ○ He characterized the project as something that “rises to the level of a capital improvement by a government agency.” ○ However, he stated that it probably does not rise high enough on the county's list of priorities. ○ He explained that the county has many other priorities addressed on a yearly basis. ○ Mr. Pehnke stated that the county's inability or lack of funding to move forward with the project does not change its desire to have the improvement completed. ○ In this case, he stated that the county has the ability to have the improvement completed at a private entity’s cost. - Ms. Klein asked whether Essex County does not have the money to put a traffic light at Oval Road and Eagle Rock Avenue if it wanted one. Mr. Pehnke clarified that it would depend on whether the project rose to the level of priority among the county’s long list of priorities. - Ms. Klein characterized Mr. Pehnke’s explanation as meaning that the improvement is a large enough priority for Essex County to want it, but that the county was essentially waiting for someone else to fund it. Mr. Pehnke responded that the improvement is something the county considers desirable and that the county sees the benefit of it.
10 - Ms. Klein asked what other private clubs Mr. Pehnke had used as a basis for making this type of change to a major road. She questioned whether changing the roadway was being justified primarily to accommodate the Country Club’s driveway and additional parking spaces. Mr. Pehnke responded that the Country Club driveway itself would not warrant the signal. He stated that the signal is warranted at its current location and that the driveway is being moved to where the signal is appropriately placed. - Ms. Klein stated that Crestmont Country Club had previously come before the board three other times when it wanted to put in a traffic light. She noted that those applications did not propose placing the signal at this location, despite Oval Road having existed for approximately 40 years. Mr. Pehnke responded that those applications were made “for whatever reason they were made.” - Ms. Klein asked whether anyone had polled the public who actually uses Oval Road to determine whether they wanted a traffic light or believed one was needed. Mr. Pehnke responded that the current hearing is the public meeting and public input. - Ms. Klein asked how often Pehnke drives through the intersection. Mr. Pehnke stated that he had been through the intersection quite a few times over the last two years to observe conditions. - Lori Hassell, at 61 Lapis Circle, asked whether there is a parking shortage problem associated with the current application. Mr. Pehnke stated that Mr. Cote would address the matter in greater detail. He explained that the Country Club is looking to provide some additional parking because it is experiencing a little bit of a struggle during their peak periods. - Ms. Hassell asked how many peak periods there are and how many total parking spaces the Country Club currently has. Mr. Pehnke deferred both questions to the manager’s prior testimony and Mr. Cote’s upcoming testimony. - Ms. Hassell asked for additional clarity regarding whether a right-turn-only egress had been investigated. Mr. Pehnke responded no - Ms. Hassell asked whether Mr. Pehnke felt that the light was more for the benefit of Crestmont members than for the community using Oval Road and Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Pehnke disagreed. He reiterated that the proposal is a substantial public improvement that benefits the community living off Oval Road. He acknowledged that it also
val Road and Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Pehnke disagreed. He reiterated that the proposal is a substantial public improvement that benefits the community living off Oval Road. He acknowledged that it also provides Crestmont Country Club with an opportunity to improve its egress and safety. - Keith Sly, representing Pleasantdale Chateau, located at 757 Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Sly stated that he noticed a median shown on the proposed site plan on the Pleasantdale Chateau side of Oval Road. He asked how the proposed median would affect left turns into Pleasantdale Chateau’s main entrance. Mr. Pehnke walked through the Pleasantdale Chateau frontage on the plan. Mr. Pehnke explained that what appears as a median is essentially still a double yellow line. Mr. Pehnke stated that there would be no restriction or change in movements into or out of Pleasantdale Chateau. - Mr. Sly clarified that both areas where the driveways lead to the gatehouse are entrances only. He stated that, based on the diagram, it appeared that the median could affect oncoming traffic attempting to turn left into the property. Mr. Pehnke responded that there is no change to the driveway access. He stated that the driveway remains accessible across the painted area and that the movement is permissible. - Mr. Sly asked whether, in Mr. Pehnke’s professional opinion, the proposed design could add confusion for the average motorist because it appears to be a median. Mr. Pehnke responded no, this is a typical situation on arterial roads and that there is nothing prohibitive about the design.
11 - Mr. Sly asked whether the proposed signal could affect or require movement of existing power lines on the Pleasantdale Chateau property. Mr. Pehnke responded that there should be no impact on the power lines on the property. - Mr. Sly asked how the proposed signal would affect queuing and the ability of vehicles to turn into the Pleasantdale Chateau property or gatehouse. Mr. Pehnke responded that the situation depends on the time of day. He stated that, for the most part, the intersection is showing “excellent operations” and good levels of service along the main line. - Mr. Sly asked Mr. Pehnke, to help him understand the amount of traffic flow currently exiting the Crestmont Country Club property. Mr. Pehnke explained that the traffic volume varies because the Country Club also has event-type traffic, which occurs based on different factors and has some seasonality. ○ On a typical day, Country Club membership traffic is relatively low in the morning as the day starts. ○ As the afternoon progresses, the Country Club sees approximately 50 to 60 vehicles per hour egressing the property. ○ During those same hours, Oval Road experiences variations in volume ranging from approximately 90 vehicles per hour to 120 vehicles per hour. ○ Eagle Rock Avenue itself experiences in excess of 900 vehicles per hour. ○ He explained that on a typical day, the morning is a little lighter than the evening. ○ Mid-morning traffic drops off, mid-afternoon traffic drops off, and then traffic comes back up. ○ Event-type traffic on a Saturday or in the evenings generally occurs when roadway traffic flows are down. - Mr. Sly asked whether Mr. Pehnke was saying that a range of 50 cars in an hour was what all of the proposed changes were being pursued for. Mr. Pehnke explained that the application is addressing conditions at the Country Club that include: ○ Some parking; ○ Internal circulation; and ○ A driveway that the Country Club would like to improve the safety of. - Mr. Sly asked whether Mr. Pehnke felt that advantaging one business in the area should be done “at the sake of another.” Mr. Pehnke stated that he did not think anybody was being advantaged with the application. - Joseph Panullo, at Holton Lane, Essex Fells, asked who had discretion over the proposed four-way intersection where the traffic signal is proposed: the Town of West Orange or Essex County. Mr. Pehnke
Joseph Panullo, at Holton Lane, Essex Fells, asked who had discretion over the proposed four-way intersection where the traffic signal is proposed: the Town of West Orange or Essex County. Mr. Pehnke stated that Essex County is the jurisdictional agent along Eagle Rock Avenue. He explained that the Planning Board has jurisdiction over the site plan and the layout of the egress as part of the application. However, the signal improvements, intersection improvements, and signal operation all fall within the jurisdiction of the County. - Mr. Panullo asked who has discretion over crosswalks and sidewalks on all four sides of what would be a signalized intersection. Mr. Pehnke stated that this would be the County. - Mr. Panullo asked whether Essex County ultimately has discretion over what the final form of all four sides of the intersection would look like should the project go forward. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that the County will review and provide comment and input to the design plans. He explained that those comments and input will be incorporated into the final design plans as part of the County's review and approval process. - Mr. Panullo asked whether any of that design for crosswalks or sidewalks on all sides was included in the current plan. He asked whether anything else had been submitted. Mr. Pehnke stated that the preliminary plan set had been submitted to the Planning Board.
12 A more full plan set had just been submitted to the County to start its approval and review process. - Mr. Panullo stated that he believed Chairman Bagoff had asked that sidewalks be added on both sides of the driveway on the Crestmont side of Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Panullo asked whether that was correct. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that this was what Chairman Bagoff had requested. - Mr. Panullo asked whether the requested sidewalks were anticipated in the drawing currently displayed. Mr. Pehnke stated that they were not. - Mr. Panullo then asked whether adding the sidewalks would encroach on the existing Crestmont frontage. Mr. Pehnke explained that the sidewalks would fall within the area that had already been graded and was intended to be dedicated to the County. - Mr. Panullo asked whether, if the sidewalks were put into place, they would affect the relief sought in the application. He specifically referenced the depth of the slope and setbacks of improvements. Mr. Pehnke answered, no. - Mr. Panullo asked whether the design, crosswalks, and related elements were at the discretion of Essex County. Mr. Pehnke clarified that the intersection is under the jurisdiction of Essex County. - Mr. Panullo asked whether the traffic coming into the intersection from any direction, including ingress and egress from all four sides, is material to whatever is engineered from a design standpoint. He specifically referenced level of service, sacking, and other related considerations. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that it is all taken into consideration. - Mr. Panullo asked what changes, if any, would need to occur to Oval Road to accommodate the application. Mr. Pehnke stated that there would be no widening on Oval Road. He explained that there would be: ○ Regulatory signage ○ Updated striping ○ A stop bar associated with the signal rather than a stop sign ○ Removal of the stop sign ○ Pedestrian crosswalk striping. - Mr. Panullo asked whether a traffic study was done to determine how much traffic leaving Oval Road during peak times goes east, goes west, and goes south toward Route 280. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that a traffic study was done. - Mr. Panullo asked for the date of the study. Mr. Pehnke stated that the study submitted with the application is dated January 2026. - Mr. Panullo referred to the prior application across the street involving the Highlands and the application from
File revisions (1)
- Oct 7, 2026
2e4c7c42a270337,233 bytes