Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026

7 1 26 WO PB Draft Minutes

Preserved file SHA-2562e4c7c42a270498c0c3576e47d85bc4d985dc27f3a8f765c33c1de4f25d6b446

Indexed text

Page 12

r. Pehnke stated that the study submitted with the application is dated January 2026. - Mr. Panullo referred to the prior application across the street involving the Highlands and the application from Walter Lubanecki from 2018–2019. He stated that he believed the County would require another study for that side. Mr. Panullo asked Mr. Pehnke whether he agreed. Mr. Pehnke stated that the study had already been done and was documented within the January 2026 study he had referenced. - Mr. Panullo confirmed that the study referenced by Mr. Pehnke took into account all four sides, including traffic coming out of Oval Road. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that it did. - Mr. Panullo asked approximately how many feet it is from Oval Road turning right onto Eagle Rock Avenue to the Laurel Avenue traffic signal. Mr. Pehnke stated that it is roughly 800 to 900 feet. - Mr. Panullo asked how many cars leaving Oval Road head south. Mr. Pehnke initially stated that it depends on the time of day and was asked to reference the worst case. He explained that they had taken the opportunity to obtain a new traffic count before schools closed, at the beginning of June.

Page 13

13 - Mr. Panullo asked whether the new traffic count was on the record and whether it was in the file or on the agenda. Mr. Pehnke clarified that it was not in the file because the data had just been collected. ○ He stated that the new data was consistent with the data already in the record and documented in the traffic study. ○ Mr. Pehnke described the new count as “very, very similar” to the data in the existing record. ○ Mr. Schkolnick asked Mr. Pehnke to reference the information contained in the January 21, 2026 report. - Mr. Pehnke referenced the Oval Road approach. - He explained that the heavier peak periods generally occur in the morning. - From 6:00 to 7:00 a.m., approximately: ○ 89 vehicles were making a right turn; and ○ 69 vehicles were making a left turn. - The following hour dropped to: ○ 66 vehicles making a right turn; and ○ 45 vehicles making a left turn. - During the evening hours, particularly 5:00 to 6:00 p.m., the volumes were approximately: ○ 63 vehicles making a right turn; and ○ 38 vehicles making a left turn. - Mr. Pehnke emphasized that the volumes vary throughout the day. - Mr. Panullo then asked how many of the vehicles making a right turn are actually intending to go south, meaning they would eventually turn left onto Laurel Avenue and get across three lanes to do so. He asked how many of the vehicles exiting Oval Road are intending to go south rather than simply traveling east or west. Mr. Pehnke explained that they do not trace the travel path as vehicles leave the site. - Mr. Panullo clarified that his question was what it would take for cars, and how many cars, to make the right turn onto Eagle Rock and get across three lanes to the left-turn lane for Laurel Avenue in order to head toward Route 280. Mr. Pehnke explained that vehicles are doing the same thing today, except that under the traffic signal they could directly turn into the appropriate lane and continue down because there would be no opposing traffic. - Mr. Panullo asked whether Oval Road would remain one lane in and one lane out. Mr. Pehnke stated that they are looking at restriping the wide approach to provide a left-turn lane and a through/right-turn lane on Oval Road. - Mr. Panullo asked whether that would require widening the road. Mr. Pehnke stated not at all. He explained that the road is substantially wide today. - Mr. Panullo referred Mr. Pehnke testimony

Page 13

oad. - Mr. Panullo asked whether that would require widening the road. Mr. Pehnke stated not at all. He explained that the road is substantially wide today. - Mr. Panullo referred Mr. Pehnke testimony about average daily trips generated by the proposed development. He stated that, since the prior application did not take into account average daily trips in total, but the purpose of the signal was also justified in that application, he believed there would be approximately 5,300 trips. He asked how the traffic would be handled in one lane. Mr. Pehnke stated that the analysis has always taken into account the potential development of the Highlands. He stated that the analysis is a peak-hour, hourly analysis reflected in the submitted study. He stated that the Highlands development is considered in the analysis. - Ms. Joyce Rudin, at Woodland Avenue, asked whether 63 vehicles exiting during peak hours is considered significant. Mr. Pehnke stated that he was not sure of the origin of the 63

Page 14

14 - Ms. Rudin clarified that Mr. Pehnke had mentioned 63 vehicles exiting during an hour in his study. Mr. Pehnke explained that he had discussed a variation in traffic and had provided specifics regarding right turns and left turns. In general, he stated that coming out of Oval Road, volumes are between approximately 90 and 120 vehicles per hour. Regarding the Country Club, on a typical day, volumes are very low in the morning. As the afternoon progresses, the Country Club sees approximately 40 to 60 vehicles per hour during the evening hours. Mr. Pehnke again emphasized that the volume varies by hour. - Ms. Rudin asked whether the police, fire department, and EMS had reviewed the proposal. Mr. Pehnke stated that he could not speak to what the Town's professionals may have reviewed. - Ms. Rudin asked whether adding the traffic light could affect emergency response times. Mr. Pehnke stated that it would not. - Ms. Rudin asked what evidence demonstrates that the traffic signal is the “absolute best and least intrusive solution” to the problem. Mr. Pehnke stated that least intrusive is not a criteria. He explained that the goal is to solve multiple concerns at the intersection. These concerns include: ○ Volume operation ○ Substandard geometry ○ Some questionable sight lines ○ Operations. - Ms. Rudin asked why the engineers did not look at getting traffic off of Eagle Rock Avenue and evaluate an exit at Laurel Avenue. Mr. Pehnke stated that Laurel is just as heavy a county road. He said there is therefore no advantage to trying to concentrate all of the traffic there. - Ms. Rudin stated that there is a lot of land on Laurel and a lot of land that could potentially be exited from Laurel. She asked whether any other rerouting of internal traffic patterns had been considered. Mr. Pehnke stated that the application before the Board is the application being evaluated. He referred to testimony from the last meeting and from the Country Club manager. He explained that the application is also associated with the intent to improve the intersection of Oval Road. - Ms. Rudin asked what the total cost of installation for the traffic light would be. Mr. Pehnke stated that he had not calculated it. - Ms. Rudin asked who would be responsible for paying for all of the improvements. Mr. Pehnke stated that the application carries the burden of the costs. - Ms. Rudin asked who

Page 14

had not calculated it. - Ms. Rudin asked who would be responsible for paying for all of the improvements. Mr. Pehnke stated that the application carries the burden of the costs. - Ms. Rudin asked who the application was being paid for by. Mr. Pehnke stated the applicant, Crestmont Country Club, and that Crestmont is coordinating with West Essex Highlands. - Ms. Rudin asked whether there are annual maintenance and electricity costs associated with the traffic signal. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that there are such costs. - Ms. Rudin asked who would bear those expenses. Mr. Pehnke explained that, generally, in a situation such as this, the County will enter into a developer's agreement with the property owners. The agreement would apportion those costs between the County and the property owner as they see fit. - Ms. Rudin asked Mr. Pehnke whether he had said that Laurel Avenue is “just as bad as Eagle Rock.” Mr. Pehnke clarified that Laurel is also a heavily traveled county road. - Ms. Rudin asked whether it would be safer to drive some of the traffic to Eagle Rock rather than pushing it onto Laurel or “circuiting it through Laurel.” Mr. Pehnke responded, not necessarily. - Ms. Rudin asked what he meant by “not necessarily.” Mr. Pehnke explained that the impacts would have to be studied. He stated that this had not been done. He also stated

Page 15

15 that there was no reason to do that because it was not the application before the Board that evening. - Ms. Rudin asked why that study was not done. She stated that if the concern was that there is a lot of traffic coming out of the Country Club, which is a very large land mass, she questioned why another study was not done on another egress that could be constructed. Mr. Pehnke stated the application arises from a requirement of West Essex Highlands. He explained that the requirement comes from a settlement agreement with the Township. Under that settlement agreement, West Essex Highlands is required to pursue traffic signalization. - Ms. Rudin asked whether Mr. Pehnke was testifying that the whole application was really not being driven by Crestmont Country Club. Mr. Pehnke stated that it was both, but that it was also being driven by another application, which the Board had recently rejected. - Dr. Deborah Fruchtman-Butensky, at 11 Rapley Court, asked Mr. Pehnke whether he had ever done a traffic study to prove, “beyond the shadow of the doubt,” that traffic on Oval Road would actually be improved rather than impeded by having the proposed traffic light there. Mr. Pehnke responded that the traffic studies they had done and prepared show that the intersection would be substantially improved as part of the application. - Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky asked whether the study also demonstrated that the traffic signal would not cause traffic backup during school hours and in the morning, and asked how that was done as a hypothetical. Mr. Pehnke clarified that it was not done as a hypothetical. He explained that there are analysis procedures available to engineers that are used nationwide and are accepted by the transportation industry. - Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky asked whether there was also a traffic study done to assess how the light would affect traffic going into and out of Pleasantdale Chateau. Mr. Pehnke stated that this was included in the analysis. He said that people coming out of the Chateau would have the advantage of the traffic signal and reiterated that, in his opinion, ingress to the Chateau would not be impacted. - Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky stated there is no longer bus service going down and east-west on Eagle Rock Avenue because the DeCamp line is gone. Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky then questioned how many traffic accidents had occurred at the site

Page 15

there is no longer bus service going down and east-west on Eagle Rock Avenue because the DeCamp line is gone. Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky then questioned how many traffic accidents had occurred at the site referenced in the five-year study and whether there had been a two-year study. Mr. Pehnke stated that they did not have pedestrian accident data, but stated that the proposed improvement provides an opportunity for and a safe crossing location at an appropriate location along Eagle Rock Avenue that does not exist today. - Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky asked where the public could see the traffic studies that Mr. Pehnke was referring to. Mr. Pehnke stated that the study is in the record and is available for inspection. - Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky asked why a right-turn-only egress had never been evaluated so that the traffic light would not be needed. Mr. Pehnke deferred to the record from the last meeting, which he said laid the foundation for the overall objectives of the project. He explained that the project is not just about the driveway and ties into the improvements at Oval Road, making it a “bigger package.” - Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky questioned how they could know that the project was an improvement and not a detriment. Mr. Pehnke responded that there are identifiable substandard conditions, which he had walked through during the last meeting. He stated that these conditions are readily observable by an engineer as well as the public. - Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky then asked whether there was a difference between improvements for the Country Club people and improvements for residents who reside at the Grand and the Highlands. She specifically asked whether Mr. Pehnke had considered the impact to the residents alone, rather than statements about improving egress and

Page 16

16 ingress to the Country Club. Mr. Pehnke responded absolutely. He stated that the improvements provide safety improvements and operational improvements “without a doubt” to the motoring public traveling along Eagle Rock Avenue through the intersection. He further stated that traffic signal control would provide improved and enhanced operation for the ability to egress Oval Road and the Country Club under signal protection. - Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky suggested that the Planning Board hire an independent traffic assessor to assess the “veracity” of Mr. Pehnke’s studies. Mr. Pehnke responded that this is done through the county engineer and county traffic engineer, whose jurisdiction includes the intersection. He stated that they conduct a full review in accordance with the same standards that he utilizes. - Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky questioned whether Mr. Pehnke was saying that he was “totally objective” and that there were no “ulterior motives.” Mr. Pehnke clarified that, in terms of the design, identifying safety improvements, evaluating the operation of the intersection, and considering the benefits it provides, he did not agree with the suggestion that his analysis was based on ulterior motives. - Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky stated that the study was incomplete because Mr. Pehnke had not done a before-and-after comparison of the past five years versus the past two years, when there was no longer a bus going down Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Pehnke responded no and stated that a bus going up and down Eagle Rock Avenue has no impact on the analysis. - Mr. Justin Goldsman noted that Eagle Rock had recently been repaved and that residents had experienced traffic delays on Eagle Rock. Mr. Goldsman asked whether there had been any consideration as to why the application did not seem to take advantage of the timing of the recent repaving and traffic delays. Mr. Goldsman then asked whether an increase in traffic delays caused by a new stop sign or traffic light could lead to subsequent changes in traffic patterns. Mr. Pehnke responded that they do not control the timing. He explained that there is a process involved with progressing plans, approvals, and permits that the applicant and engineers do not control. Regarding impacts on traffic patterns in the area, Mr. Pehnke stated that the signal would not have any impact on traffic patterns in the area. He said it would provide

Page 16

t and engineers do not control. Regarding impacts on traffic patterns in the area, Mr. Pehnke stated that the signal would not have any impact on traffic patterns in the area. He said it would provide for safe control of the egress movements from Oval Road and from the Country Club. - Mr. Goldsman said he believed Mr. Pehnke had testified that sidewalks might be a recommendation suggested by the Chairman. Mr. Goldsman asked whether they would cause any decrease in the width of Eagle Rock or impede the dimensions of the road. Mr. Pehnke responded that sidewalks would not change any of the designs discussed. - Mr. Penullo asked Mr. Pehnke to confirm that the lights between the new proposed light and Laurel Avenue would be synchronized. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that they would be synchronized. - Mr. Penullo asked whether synchronization of the two lights would be for traffic coming out of either side of what would be the existing Oval and the new driveway, or whether it would also take into account traffic that meets at Laurel Avenue and Eagle Rock. Mr. Pehnke explained that the design prioritizes the flow on the main line, which is Eagle Rock Avenue. He stated that it would be done by analysis, setting up a “platoon and progression” to make sure traffic progresses along the corridor “as close to, as… or better than what it does, today.” - Mr. Penullo raised the issue of eastbound traffic on Eagle Rock turning onto Laurel Avenue. He stated that the right-turn lane can become blocked by two cars and that people making a right onto Laurel in the right lane, when two cars deep, cannot make the right turn. Mr. Penullo explained that some of that traffic proceeds to make a left into the

Page 17

17 existing entrance to the Crestmont Country Club. He stated that when that traffic gets onto Laurel and stops to make that left, it encounters traffic heading north on Laurel into Eagle Rock. Mr. Penullo asked whether that interaction would be taken into account in the signalization that synchronizes the two lights. Mr. Pehnke responded that it would be taken into account. - Mr. Penullo then asked about a bus stop. He stated that he believed one had originally been proposed, at least on the eastbound side of Eagle Rock, as a possibility, and asked whether that was correct. Mr. Pehnke stated that the applicant was prepared to install a bus stop. - Mr. Penullo asked whether, in that event, there might be a westbound bus lane or a way to take traffic in the alternate direction. Mr. Pehnke responded that passengers would be able to disembark either before or after the intersection and use the crosswalks at the signal. - Mr. Penullo clarified that he was asking about traffic going westbound on Eagle Rock. Mr. Pehnke responded that if a westbound bus chose to stop, it would probably stop on the near side of the intersection, and passengers would then be able to use the crosswalks through the intersection. - Mr. Penullo asked whether the bus stop would occur in the existing right lane or whether there would be additional space added to allow the bus to stop without impeding traffic. Mr. Pehnke clarified that bus stops are always in the curb lane. - Mr. Penullo asked whether that meant the right lane or whether new space would be added to allow the bus to stop without impeding traffic. Mr. Pehnke stated that they would not be installing any pull-outs. - Mr. Penullo then confirmed that Eagle Rock would not have to be widened at any location to accommodate bus traffic in two different directions. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that there would be no widening for the bus stops because the stops are always from the live lane. - Mr. Penullo asked how this would be accommodated from a traffic-management standpoint and how the situation would be accounted for after the fact if bus service returns. Mr. Pehnke explained that it would depend on the operations and frequency of the bus. He stated that it would be a matter of properly signing the bus stop location and providing an accommodation from a sidewalk standpoint. Mr. Pehnke stated that there would be no changes or impacts on

File revisions (1)