Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Nov 4, 2026

9 2 26 WO PB Draft Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256e517e0133e501772133e3ec02fd3a94ed8399b86900e5b5caa6858d51f060903

Indexed text · page 26

Show all pages
Page 26

26 trees with younger trees, which could take decades to grow, would not immediately replace the functions of the existing root systems. ○ Mr. Moronski responded that the steep slope disturbance and tree removal were directly related to the requested variances. He reiterated that the applicant was attempting to strike a balance and minimize disturbance to the extent possible. ○ Mr. Moronski acknowledged that trees would be removed but stated that the replacement trees would fill in the gaps over time. He explained that the tree replacement needed to be weighed against the drainage improvements proposed for both the country club property and Eagle Rock Avenue. - Council President Scarpa stated that she remained concerned about the potential for additional stormwater runoff and also about the effect of traffic on Pleasantdale Chateau. ○ Mr. Moronski stated that the drainage and roadway improvements represented public benefits and that the application attempted to balance those improvements with minimizing disturbance - Council President Scarpa stated that she remained concerned. She referred to her own neighborhood, where mature trees had been removed and young trees planted more than a decade earlier, while neighboring properties continued to experience increased flooding. ○ Mr. Cote responded that the majority of the proposed replacement trees would be approximately 4-inch caliper trees. He explained that although these trees were smaller than the mature trees being removed, a 4-inch caliper tree was more substantial than the approximately 2.5-inch caliper trees commonly used for replacement planting in other municipalities. ○ Mr. Cote stated that using 4-inch caliper trees would provide a larger starting diameter and more substantial replacement planting. - Council President Scarpa stated that she continued to picture a large, beautiful, mature tree that might have been growing for 100 years being replaced by a much smaller tree. She questioned how many years it would take for the replacement trees to develop root systems capable of performing the same function as the mature trees. ○ Mr. Cote explained that the Township's tree replacement ordinance uses a multiplier based on the diameter of trees being removed. He stated that replacing one mature tree with multiple new trees would ultimately create a larger combined root structure. ○ Mr. Cote described the

Page 26

iplier based on the diameter of trees being removed. He stated that replacing one mature tree with multiple new trees would ultimately create a larger combined root structure. ○ Mr. Cote described the Township's tree replacement requirements as a very high standard within the industry and stated that the ordinance was designed to help address the concerns raised by Council President Scarpa. ADDITIONAL TESTIMONY - Mr. Schkolnick asked Mr. Cote to briefly explain the proposed tree replacement numbers in greater detail. - Mr. Cote explained that, in response to the Township Planner's comments, 11 trees proposed within the parking area would not be counted toward the required tree replacement total. He stated that the applicant would add 11 replacement trees to account for that adjustment. - Mr. Cote stated that the original replacement plan included 586 trees, consisting of 303 trees shown in the main project area along the frontage, 239 additional trees elsewhere on the overall property, and 44 trees addressed through off-site planting or a fee in lieu. - Mr. Cote explained that the off-site planting or fee-in-lieu component would increase from 44 to 55 trees to account for the additional 11 replacement trees.

File revisions (1)