Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Dec 2, 2026

Crestmont_September_2_2026_Condensed_with_Keyword_Index

Preserved file SHA-25657c034a28d1c8a980a9438693f4fe6cb0ac77cfc3fa04a551290b5558b588db8

Indexed text

Page 13

y a different engineer and under a different, you know, application. Again, I apologize, I was not involved in that application. But I'm familiar with the fact that those improvements already underlie our existing -- as our existing conditions for our proposed improvements. So that's the familiarity that I'm picking up for where they left off. MS. BENNETT: Were any of the improvements1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 45 now that are being contemplated by this board required or discussed in those prior 2023 Planning Board or 2024 zoning Board approvals? That's what I'm trying to get at. MR. COTE: That's not a -- I apologize, that's not a question for me, if you're asking that question to the board? Is that where you're directing the question? MS. BENNETT: No. I'm asking you if your review of the material that's in front of the board now, including the 2023 planning board application and approval or the 2024 Zoning board application and approval, I'm asking you if these improvements that are now in front of the board were contemplated, required, or discussed in those prior applications, if you know. MR. COTE: I do not know, I'm not aware of that. MS. BENNETT: And are there any conditions that you're aware of that have changed since those approvals that would make these improvements necessary now? MR. COTE: From -- that would be an operational question more than an engineering question. Not something I can answer. MS. BENNETT: Chairman, I have one additional1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 46 question, just to avoid -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Go right ahead. MS. BENNETT: -- having to come -- thank you. Thank you, Sir. Is this application correcting an unforeseen consequence of any of the previously approved development or use? MR. COTE: Not that I'm aware of. MS. BENNETT: Thank you, Sir. Thank you, Chairman. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you very much. Again, do any members of the public have any questions for Mr. Cote on his testimony? Just remember, you get one shot this evening, not -- not multiple times, so ask the best questions that’ll help the planning board understand the application better. Thank you. Please raise your hand and be identified if you have any questions for Mr. Cote. ZOOM OPERATOR: Zoom User, please state your name and address for the

Page 13

oard understand the application better. Thank you. Please raise your hand and be identified if you have any questions for Mr. Cote. ZOOM OPERATOR: Zoom User, please state your name and address for the record. MR. COHEN: Lawrence Cohen, 20 Lincoln Avenue, West Orange. ZOOM OPERATOR: Go ahead. MR. COHEN: Thank you. Mr. Cote, I have a question. In your professional opinion as an engineer, what do you think about the wisdom of the current,

Page 14

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 47 driveway that's been used for many, many years, and has a lot of visibility on either side, even though you mentioned the 90-degree angle to looking left. What do you think about that when they were making this, and they chose this area? Do you think it was a wise decision, and it's been time-tested? What is your professional opinion? Thank you. MR. COTE: I can't opine on the wisdom of that driveway. I can only opine on the fact that that driveway's alignment is not a proper alignment for an exiting maneuver from the site. So, to answer your question, that's what I can answer. I can't -- I don't have any of the history of the wisdom, you want to say, relative to why they did what they did. MR. COHEN: Okay, but did they choose -- do you think they chose that, with the visibility, they're pretty much, good sight to the left and good sight vision to the right, and they tried to pick from that area and had some seclusion and privacy for their country club. Do you think that was part of it? MR. COTE: I couldn't tell you. I don't have -- I don't have any knowledge of their original reason for doing that. Other than what I said about the fact that it's not -- it's not what I would design as an engineer today.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 48 MR. COHEN: And the steepness is not so steep compared to the -- MR. COTE: It varies along that driveway. MR. COHEN: Okay. That's my only question. Thank you so much. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you very much. Do any member of the public have any questions of Mr. Cote on his testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. ZOOM OPERATOR: Seth Weisleder, please state your name and address for the record. MR. WEISLEDER: Yes. Hi. Good evening, Seth Weisleder, 17 Howell Drive, West Orange, New Jersey. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Go right ahead, Sir. MR. WEISLEDER: Can you hear me? Okay. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Yes. Go right ahead, Sir. MR. WEISLEDER: Mr. Cote, you said the water currently runs onto Eagle Rock Avenue without being detained. Can you describe a little bit about what that actual problem is causing today, and how is your application actually fixing it? MR. COTE: So, with respect to the runoff, the existing runoff is not controlled by any type of stormwater detention system or anything that

Page 14

using today, and how is your application actually fixing it? MR. COTE: So, with respect to the runoff, the existing runoff is not controlled by any type of stormwater detention system or anything that slows that water down. What we're doing, basically, is capturing1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 49 that water, and as a result, being able to slow it down. We're also making improvements in Eagle Rock Avenue. The history of Eagle Rock Avenue and the date to which the original designs were prepared predate the current regulations, so we have the opportunity here to update those stormwater pipes in Eagle Rock to bring them up to today's code. So those two elements provide the improvements along Eagle Rock that don't exist today. MR. WEISLEDER: Right, but that's a very small portion of Eagle Rock. It's not going to change all of Eagle Rock and make it safer, would it? MR. COTE: It's the portion that we're working with. That's within our juris -- that's within our limits of our property. MR. WEISLEDER: Which is how big, because I'm still not understanding the actual specific problem it's causing. MR. COTE: I -- I don't understand the question? I don't understand the question. MR. WEISLEDER: Like, where’s the date? Well, you're saying that there's a problem and it needs fixing. There's cars that are driving on it. Where's the data? Where's the study that shows that there's an actual problem today?1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 50 MR. COTE: So if you’re asking -- MR. WEISLEDER: And you’re saying your application’s making it better. Making what better? MR. COTE: So let me -- MR. WEISLEDER: Yeah. MR. COTE: So if you're asking relative to a traffic element, that's already been addressed by my traffic engineer in his testimony and cross-examination. With respect to the -- MR. WEISLEDER: No. More to water. Water. MR. COTE: -- water, yeah, to water, what I can tell you today is that what's out there today, by today's standards, is substandard. So the substandard element means that you have conveyances that aren't adequately conveying them based upon the current storm events. Again, if you understand the history of the regulations, the regulations have adopted new and increased flow rates associated with storms, in effect, to try and address global warming as

Page 14

storm events. Again, if you understand the history of the regulations, the regulations have adopted new and increased flow rates associated with storms, in effect, to try and address global warming as a component of their regulatory improvements. And therefore, we're -- we're implementing that in this design. And that post dates anything that's been constructed prior relative to older standards. So that's the answer to the question.

Page 15

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 51 MR. WEISLEDER: Right. On how large of a portion of Eagle Rock is that? MR. COTE: From -- from -- we're doing it from Laurel Avenue on the west end, where it intersects with Eagle Rock Avenue, to the east end of this property, to where we have control of our work. MR. WEISLEDER: Okay. So you've explained that the retaining wall and storm water systems are needed because of the parking lot grading. If Crestmont wasn't adding these additional parking spaces, would you still need the same wall, grading, and stormwater work to take place? MR. COTE: I would still -- I would still need stormwater for both. The walls are associated with creating adequate grades for the parking lot, and like I spoke to earlier in my testimony. But the actual detention systems would also be required because of the widening of Eagle Rock Avenue to provide the additional lanes that are proposed and widening for the center left turn lane. MR. WEISLEDER: Right, but the stormwater work, I'm specifically talking about the parking lot, not the -- not Eagle Rock. I think we can look -- MR. COTE: The parking lot is a component -- MR. WEISLEDER: -- separately. Correct?1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 52 MR. COTE: I am -- I answered your question stating that the roadway improvements for Eagle Rock alone would require stormwater management, the basins that you were asking about, and that we've combined the improvements for the parking lots with the stormwater associated with the widening of Eagle Rock to make it one system. So they're both necessary for the purpose of the overall development. MR. WEISLEDER: But one could be done without the other, right? MR. COTE: Anything can be done independent of each other, but that's not relevant to this application. MR. WEISLEDER: Okay. Just asking. Is the widening and regarding of Eagle Rock mainly being done because of the new exit and traffic signal, or would that work have to be done anyway? MR. COTE: The work was requested, relative to putting in a signal associated with the settlement agreement. And if I understand correctly, that ultimately, from my traffic engineer's discussions, that the county is in favor of this project. MR. WEISLEDER: Okay. And did you happen to look at any other ways to lay out

Page 15

understand correctly, that ultimately, from my traffic engineer's discussions, that the county is in favor of this project. MR. WEISLEDER: Okay. And did you happen to look at any other ways to lay out the parking so you could add other spaces without as much grading, or1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 53 having a huge retaining wall or tree removal or -- MR. COTE: There was -- MR. WEISLEDER: -- doing extra work along Eagle Rock? MR. COTE: This is the one we came up with to minimize the impacts. So the answer is yes, and this is the one we came up with to minimize. MR. WEISLEDER: But there could be alternative ways to do it without doing all of this, correct? MR. COTE: You could -- you could design it 100 different ways, but again, you know, our efforts were to minimize the impacts. So that's the plan that we came up with, and that's before the board tonight. MR. WEISLEDER: Okay. So you said the existing driveway is difficult because of the angle and visibility. What is preventing you from moving or redesigning the parking lot and driveway in a different way that would address these problems without all these other site changes that are needed and that you're asking for? MR. COTE: Again, we're asking for this relative to minimize the amount of impacts. I could design it and have a much greater impact on the overall area. I could do -- I could increase impervious, have1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 54 more issues with tree removal. Again, you're asking a question as to, could I design it in a number of different ways? The answer is yes, but this is the way that was the most conducive for minimizing impacts to the existing trees, minimizing impacts to steep slopes. So all those conditions that I'm asking for the variance, are supported by this application and the nature of the design. MR. WEISLEDER: Okay. So if you're adding more water into the stormwater for the county, does the country club become responsible, or the construction become responsible to assist the county in that stormwater increase? MR. COTE: The county's actually getting the benefit of the overall design by improving their existing structures, to my testimony earlier about the fact that this is actually taking substandard pipes and networks in the roadway and improving them. So

Page 15

t of the overall design by improving their existing structures, to my testimony earlier about the fact that this is actually taking substandard pipes and networks in the roadway and improving them. So the county's getting the benefit of this improvement already as a function of the project. MR. WEISLEDER: And in any way, does this affect West Orange stormwater containment or control? MR. COTE: This is consistent with regulations in terms of the requirements of the design for the reductions in the post-development flow rates,

Page 16

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 55 and in that effect, we are improving the conditions in the downstream receiving components of this design. And that was the -- that's already been, you know, reviewed by the engineer, as well as, it has to be consistent with the town's and the county's requirements. MR. WEISLEDER: Okay. Thank you. MR. COTE: Thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Does any member of the public have any questions for Mr. Cote on his testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. ZOOM OPERATOR: Justin Goldsman, please state your name and address for the record. MR. GOLDSMAN: Justin Goldsman, Moran Road. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Go right ahead, Sir. MR. GOLDSMAN: Thank you. Thank you, planning board members and Mr. Cote. Can you tell me in your professional experience or estimation how much capacity to absorb, or prevent runoff does a standard bio-retention basin have? MR. COTE: The bio-retention is a component of water quality for the basin. It's not a retention with respect to -- it does slow down the water in some respects and serves that purpose, but its goal is for water quality, not for water quantity. Water quantity1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 56 is controlled by the outfall structure proper of the basin. MR. GOLDSMAN: Okay. So it does have a runoff component, though, as you're -- as you're saying? MR. COTE: Yeah. It filters the water before it comes into a control structure that then runs off the water on a controlled rate. Justin Goldsman: Sure. So how much in terms of a capacity quantity would that -- would a bio- retention basin have for runoff purposes? MR. COTE: It’s -- it’s -- every design is different. This design is intended to address the water quantity, the rate reductions I talked about earlier was the 50 percent of the two-year reduction of the two-year storm, 75 percent reduction down to 75 percent of the 10-year storm, and reduction down to 80 percent of the 100-year storm. So that's the -- that is the capacity component of these basins in terms of what they're able to address to reduce that stormwater runoff downstream. MR. GOLDSMAN: I appreciate that. So that's not necessarily a, you know, a numerical value, and I understand the comp -- I understand the -- MR. COTE:

Page 16

dress to reduce that stormwater runoff downstream. MR. GOLDSMAN: I appreciate that. So that's not necessarily a, you know, a numerical value, and I understand the comp -- I understand the -- MR. COTE: Yeah.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 57 MR. GOLDSMAN: I get it. So, my -- I guess my question would be, in comparison to these bio- retention basins, in terms of their capacity to reduce stormwater runoff, are you able to provide a rough estimate of how many trees that would be the equivalent of? MR. COTE: No, I have no way to equate that. But I did already state, prior to this set of questions to the earlier, comment about what the actual reductions are in those flow rates, both -- based on both the current storm design as well as that future year 2100 storm that we're required to design to. MR. GOLDSMAN: Correct, I heard that. I did hear that, and I appreciate that, but I'm trying to get at a different question here, because you've also said throughout your testimony that your impacts are -- whether they're positive or negative, you're concerned with the scope of the work as it relates to the boundaries of your project. You know, some people have asked questions about how far down does it go, and you've said it stops at the scope of your work. So my question is, if you have a bio- retention basin that you're putting in with regard to limiting the impact that your project is creating, those bio-retention basins limit the impact up to the1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Public Questions 58 point of your property whereas a tree, or 313 trees, as you're proposing to remove according to your EIS study, has a higher capacity to handle water as it flows down -- downstream for the rest of the residents on Eagle Rock Avenue. MR. COTE: I can’t -- I can’t opine on a tree-by-tree basis. I mean, sorry, so ask your question, I apologize. MR. GOLDSMAN: So, my -- MR. COTE: Ask your question. MR. GOLDSMAN: I appreciate that. No, so the point of my question is, is does one or two bio- retention basins, as you're proposed, equate to the capacity of 313 trees that you're proposing to remove? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: I’m sorry, Mr. Goldsman. He didn’t testify to anything about tree capacity equaling the bio-retention basis, so we’re going to have to move on. MR. GOLDSMAN: Okay. MR. COTE: I

File revisions (1)