Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Jul 1, 2026

July 1, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-25606070d63f2cc8bfb6a92457924418aabf3e97673b3f2b795c15b74aa405db158

Indexed text

Page 17

that it would be a matter of properly signing the bus stop location and providing an accommodation from a sidewalk standpoint. Mr. Pehnke stated that there would be no changes or impacts on any of the design features of the traffic signal. Mr. Penullo then referenced the prior application and testimony concerning Oval Road and whether it would need to be widened. He stated that Mr. Pehnke had previously represented Essex Fellows Country Club, and that under no circumstance would Oval Road need to be widened. Mr. Penullo asked whether that remained the case. Mr. Pehnke stated that it remained true. Mr. Weisleder asked whether Mr. Pehnke’s recommendation for a new traffic signal was not based on documented crashes, pedestrian studies, or alternative analysis. Mr. Pehnke corrected that the recommendation is based upon an engineering study, which includes volume analysis and volume warrants. He also stated that the recommendation is based upon observations of the existing conditions at the intersection, including sight lines and acute angles. Mr. Weisleder asked whether, given that this is a Crestmont Country Club application for Crestmont Country Club involving the parking lot and other things, Mr. Pehnke had taken into account or conducted a traffic study of the number of cars actually going in and out of Crestmont Country Club alone. Mr. Pehnke stated that he has volume data in his records that will be used for the design of the final traffic signal timing.

Page 18

Mr. Weisleder asked whether, during those times when Country Club traffic is lower, the traffic flow on the surrounding roads is also lower in the morning. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that this would be correct. Mr. Weisleder then said he was confused about the fact that the project had been discussed as being started because of the potential West Essex Highlands development, or now hypothetical development. He asked how that potential development would impact the rest of the design inside the Country Club, excluding the traffic light. Mr. Pehnke explained that the light itself is not the impactful part. Rather, it is the associated improvements considered by engineers when changing the control of an intersection. Mr. Weisleder clarified that his question was not about how the development impacts the light, but how it impacts the rest of the application. Mr. Pehnke explained that the obligation being advanced is to signalize the intersection, which involves the Country Club. Mr. Weisleder sought clarification about an earlier question from Mr. Keith Sly. Mr. Weisleder asked what the area with the diagonal striping is called. Mr. Pehnke explained that it is.a “gore area” and that there is no prohibition against crossing the gore area into a private driveway. Mr. Weisleder asked whether the area was intended to look like a median. Mr. Pehnke clarified that it is a gore area and a transition area, and reiterated that there is no prohibition against crossing it. Mr. Weisleder asked whether, if he made a left turn when the project was completed, he Would receive a ticket. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that he would not. Ms. Fruchtman-Butensky asked to go through the traffic route with her. She explained that she currently enters and exits through Oval Road to get to her house at the Grand. Ms. Fruchtman-Butensky explained that when traveling north on Laurel Avenue, she waits at the traffic light, makes a right turn, and approximately 800 feet later reaches another traffic light where she makes a left turn onto Oval Road. She asked whether, under the proposed plan, she would have to wait again at the next traffic light to make the left turn onto Oval Road. Mr. Pehnke explained that there will be a traffic light at that location, but, as she does today, she will queue to make a left instead of waiting for a gap in opposing traffic. Ms. Fruchtman-Butensky confirmed that

Page 18

ined that there will be a traffic light at that location, but, as she does today, she will queue to make a left instead of waiting for a gap in opposing traffic. Ms. Fruchtman-Butensky confirmed that there would be a left-turn arrow allowing eastbound traffic on Eagle Rock Avenue to make the left turn onto Oval Road. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that this was correct. Ms. Fruchtman-Butensky then asked for an explanation of the coordination between the traffic light at Laurel Avenue and Eagle Rock Avenue and the proposed traffic light at Oval Road. Mr. Pehnke explained that when designing a new traffic signal on a corridor, the goal is to allow traffic traveling eastbound on Eagle Rock Avenue to proceed through the Laurel Avenue intersection on a green light and then continue through the next intersection without interruption. Mr. Pehnke stated that the signal timing is designed to establish continuous progression of traffic flow along the predominant movements through the two intersections. Ms. Fruchtman-Butensky asked whether there is a computerized system on the road that measures how much traffic is traveling at a particular time of day and whether there is variability in the coordination of the two signals. Mr. Pehnke explained that traffic flow is relatively consistent, allowing the engincers to establish a timing directive that is somewhat responsive to traffic flow. Ms. Fruchtman-Butensky asked whether there are sensors in the road that allow the system to change during peak traffic flow and different times of day. Mr. Pehnke explained that sensors in the road are “a past technology” and that Essex County uses

Page 19

video detection. He confirmed that video detection is used to identify when a vehicle is present and to provide green indications based upon the underlying established timing program. Mr. Sly explained that, presumably, a large portion of Pleasantdale Chateau’s clientele arrive from Route 280 along Laurel Avenue, turning right when the light is green onto Eagle Rock Avenue and heading toward Pleasantdale Chateau. Mr. Sly explained that those vehicles would then have to cross over to the left lane of traffic and arrive at the proposed traffic light at Oval Road. When that light turns green, the vehicles would proceed another 100-plus yards, as outlined by Mr. Pehnke, and then turn left into the Pleasantdale Chateau area. Mr. Sly asked what the remedy would be for the safety and convenience of Pleasantdale Chateau’s clients when they may be left waiting before being able to allow the remainder of traffic traveling in the opposite direction to pass so they can make the left turn into the driveway. Mr. Pehnke responded that the situation would be no different from what is experienced today. He stated that the left turn is currently uncontrolled and unsignalized, requiring drivers to choose a gap in the same opposing traffic that will exist with or without the traffic signal. Mr. Sly questioned Mr. Pehnke’s certainty, explaining that traffic would then be stopped by the signal, potentially allowing traffic to build. He stated that the advantage of free- flowing traffic without a light is that there are more gaps and traffic does not pile up because it continues to flow in both directions. Mr. Sly stated that with the addition of the light; traffic would build up in both directions and could make it more difficult to turn left, and potentially right, into the Pleasantdale Chateau lot. Mr. Pehnke stated that, for the most part, the experience drivers have today is what they will experience with the signal. Mr. Pehnke explained that traffic would only stop on Eagle Rock Avenue when there are calls from the side street of Oval Road and/or the Crestmont Country Club, in coordination with what is happening at Laurel Avenue. Mr. Pehnke stated that he therefore did not see a substantial change in ingress to Pleasantdale Chateau. Mr. Sly asked Mr. Pehnke to refer him to the specific study that identified this conclusion. Mr. Pehnke stated that he had not specifically

Page 19

ee a substantial change in ingress to Pleasantdale Chateau. Mr. Sly asked Mr. Pehnke to refer him to the specific study that identified this conclusion. Mr. Pehnke stated that he had not specifically done that study and that his conclusion was based upon the location of the Pleasantdale Chateau driveway and how it generally interacts with a traffic signal. Mr. Sly asked whether this was solely Mr. Pehnke’s expert opinion or where he was gathering the information. Mr. Pehnke explained that the engineers follow standards. Ms. Klein referred to Mr. Pehnke’s statement that traffic signals and driveways are 100 feet apart and asked whether this applies to all driveways or specifically to driveways that could take in 500 cars in a span of 30 minutes because of an event. Mr. Pehnke explained that the standard basically applies to commercial driveways. He stated that the relationship is between a commercial private driveway and a traffic signal and does not depend on whether the property is a shopping center, gas station, or another type of commercial private property. Ms. Klein then questioned why Mr. Pehnke seemed particularly focused on Oval Road, stating that Oval Road “has really nothing to do with Crestmont Country Club.” She asked why so much attention was being directed toward Oval Road instead of the actual impacts related to the Crestmont site. Ms. Klein asked who decided Oval Road should be included in the analysis and whether Mr. Pehnke’s conclusions would have changed if Oval Road had been excluded from the data. Mr. Pehnke deferred to testimony provided by the Country Club manager at the previous meeting, stating that the testimony set the groundwork for the reason for the application and why they were there that evening. Ms. Klein asked whether the analysis was being conducted preemptively to support a project that had been denied twice by the same Board, rather than really being for

Page 20

Crestmont. Mr. Pehnke stated that testimony regarding this issue had been placed into the record the previous month concerning the obligations under a settlement agreement with the Township for West Essex Highlands and the Country Club’s involvement in working with it. Ms. Klein asked whether the plan, as it stood at that moment, was consistent with Safe Streets and Vision Zero. Mr. Pehnke stated that the plan incorporates all the “toolbox- type” improvements that would be consistent with Safe Streets and Vision Zero. Ms. Klein asked whether there was a written determination from the County stating that the traffic signal was warranted or whether the conclusion was based only on conversations. Mr. Pehnke stated that there is an application with the County and that the applicant had a pre-application meeting with the County. He stated that the County had indicated its concurrence that it believed this was an appropriate location for traffic control and should be controlled, and that the applicant fully expected the County to approve the application. Mr. Paul Tractenberg asked Mr. Pehnke whether, if the County were to deny the traffic signal, that would mean the project would be abandoned by the Country Club or whether there would be something the Country Club could choose to salvage. Mr. Pehnke responded that he could not speak to what the Country Club may or may not do based on that hypothetical. Ms. Luisa Casar, at 59 Davy Road, asked Mr. Pehnke whether he was aware of a massive apartment/townhouse development currently being built on Harrison Avenue in Roseland, New Jersey. Ms. Casar explained that the development is split into two primary residential phases and one future designated development. She stated that the proximity of the development to Eagle Rock Avenue is a concern because it will “undoubtedly contribute adversely” to an already high traffic volume. Ms. Casar asked whether Mr. Pehnke had taken this development into consideration because of its size. Mr. Pehnke stated that the development is taken into consideration through the growth factors that the County and State require engineers to use to accommodate regional growth patterns. Ms. Casar asked what those factors were. Mr. Pchnke explained that growth factors are published by the Department of Transportation on a yearly basis and are used to project traffic forward. Ms. Casar asked

Page 20

ar asked what those factors were. Mr. Pchnke explained that growth factors are published by the Department of Transportation on a yearly basis and are used to project traffic forward. Ms. Casar asked for an example. Mr. Pehnke stated that, for example, on arterial roads in Essex County, he believed the current growth factor was an anticipated 1.75% per year. He stated that this number is updated every year based upon traffic count data. Ms. Casar clarified that Eagle Rock Avenue is a County road, not a highway. Mr. Pehnke agreed. Ms. Casar stated that she wanted to understand how the development would impact Oval Road. Ms. Casar stated that she believed the development needed to be taken into consideration because the traffic pattern is already “incredible,” especially during rush hour, and that adding the traffic light and congestion would further exacerbate the problem. Mr. Pehnke disagreed and stated that it would actually be the opposite. He explained that growth of traffic along Eagle Rock Avenue would make it more and more difficult for residents on Oval Road and the Crestmont Country Club to exit onto Eagle Rock Avenue. Ms. Jennifer Sharret asked whether there would be digging or other work on the other side of the roadway, right above Edgemont. Mr. Pehnke stated that he was not sure he understood what she meant by digging. 20

Page 21

- Ms. Sharret clarified that she was asking whether areas near Edgemont, Beachwood, or Sherwood, including areas with trees, would be cleared to make room for the traffic light. Mr. Pehnke stated that they would not. - Ms. Sharret asked whether the project therefore consisted only of physically installing the traffic light, with nothing else being done to the surrounding area. Mr. Pehnke clarified that there would be widening into the Crestmont Country Club frontage to provide the turn lanes and the required geometry of the intersection. He stated that this impacts the Crestmont Country Club property only. - Ms. Sharret asked whether trees would be removed as part of that work. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that trees would be felled and stated that this was part of the application. - Ms. Sharret asked how many trees would be felled. Mr. Pehnke deferred to his partner, who was handling the site plan application and would be testifying next. PUBLIC COMMENTS - Lawrence Cohen, at 20 Lincoln Ave., asked Chairman Bagoff to consider rescinding the condition requiring a sidewalk going toward Laurel Avenue. o Mr. Cohen stated that he is a hiker and knows the area by walking on foot. o He said he rarely sees anyone walking in that area and noted that Crestmont Country Club workers would make a right turn and travel east on Eagle Rock toward the bus stop at Pleasant Valley Way and Eagle Rock. © He argued thatthe other direction where the sidewalk was requested is a rural or suburban area that goés toward the highway, and that “nobody’s walking there.” o Mr. Cohen characterized the sidewalk as potentially “urbanizing” a suburban area that does not need one and called it a waste. o He then discussed the concern about traffic lights and suggested that if the light at Laurel and the proposed light at Oval were synchronized, the signals should not interfere with traffic flow. o Mr. Cohen stated that he appreciated the opportunity for people to cross the road with a light. © Based on his experience walking across Eagle Rock from the south side to the north side, he described the crossing as “a difficult crossing.” © He stated that pedestrian crossings would be beneficial for Crestmont Country Club workers and anyone else who would need to cross the road. - Mr. Sly stated that Pleasantdale Chateau has operated for approximately 30 years without complaints or issues

Page 21

al for Crestmont Country Club workers and anyone else who would need to cross the road. - Mr. Sly stated that Pleasantdale Chateau has operated for approximately 30 years without complaints or issues involving people exiting via Oval Road. o He explained that most of Pleasantdale Chateau’s business is as an event facility and that the bulk of its business occurs at 5 p.m. or after, when traffic volume is high. © He reiterated concerns about the volume of traffic on Eagle Rock Avenue. o Mr. Sly expressed concern that because the driveway is within approximately 100 feet of the stop bar, it would not take many cars to cause traffic to back up into the driveway. © He stated that this could potentially inconvenience Pleasantdale Chateau’s guests and create additional difficulty in accommodating guests, including with valet operations. PRESENTATION 21

Page 22

Mr. Schkolnick asked the Board to confirm that Mr. Cote was qualified as an expert. He stated that Mr. Cote had already been qualified and that he wanted to make sure this was recognized for the record. Dr. Bagoff confirmed that everything done at the previous meeting continued to apply. Mr. Cote explained that he would go through the site civil plan set that was delivered in conjunction with the testimony of Ms. Cancellari and Mr. Pehnke. Mr. Cote began with the drawing presented at the previous hearing, identified as Exhibit Al for reference. He stated that the drawing was labeled “Project Aerial Map,” with drawing number EX05, dated June 1, 2026. Mr. Cote explained that, with north shown to the right of the site, the area containing the bulk of the proposed improvements is located between Laurel Avenue and Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote stated that he would go through the components of the on-site improvements and then switched to the site plan set proper. Mr. Cote explained that the site plans are divided into an east and west side for purposes of the sheet layout. He stated that, in terms of orientation, the Laurel Avenue and Eagle Rock Avenue intersection is shown on the westerly sheet, while Oval Road and the Crestmont Country Club driveway are shown on the easterly side. Mr. Cote began describing the westerly portion of the site. He stated that one of the improvements is the addition of a stormwater basin located at the intersection of Laurel Avenue and Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote explained that the stormwater basin will serve multiple purposes, including water quantity and water quality treatment for the site. Mr. Cote then described the entrance from Laurel Avenue. As one progresses into the site through the Laurel Avenue entrance toward the portico and main entrance to the building, the proposal includes an additional parking area adjacent to the existing parking. Mr. Cote stated that he would refer to this as the “upper level parking” in reference to the next drawing. The proposed upper-level parking area would contain 39 parking spaces and two EV parking spaces and would connect to the existing parking lot as an addition, essentially extending the parking area toward the north of the site. Mr. Cote also addressed comments from the engineers’ and planners’ letters. He explained that one of the EV spaces would be required to be an ADA EV

File revisions (1)