Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Aug 12, 2026

August 12, 2026, Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256e70fb166374efcc58fdf24a4881520d4bb1d2f20e40efa25c502122978b84f93

Indexed text · page 11

Show all pages
Page 11

Mr. Klein asked whether the Building Department would require turning templates if the applicant submitted a site plan. Chairman Bagoff stated that the Board had asked that turning templates be supplied to the Building Department and that this would be a condition of the application. o Mr. Trembulak confirmed that the applicant agreed to the condition. Ms. McGovern stated that, based on Mr. Klein's comment, she understood that turning templates were needed for both houses, but that the primary concern was the existing house and addition, where an adjustment could be made to the addition on the new house if necessary to accomplish the turning template. She asked about the status of the other house. Mr. Klein clarified that his concern was that the image shown on the right side of the latest plan would not look anything like the final plan presented to the Building Department. The parking would not be in the front, the building would be shifted forward, and the parking would be arranged in the rear. Mr. Klein further stated that, for the other property, there would not be parking in the front, the addition would be a different shape or size, the parking would be in the rear, and the driveway would be at least approximately 10 feet wide. Mr. Klein stated that he wanted to ensure that the Board was comfortable with its Building Department or Board professionals reviewing the revised plan before it went to the Building Department. Chairman Bagoff stated that one of the problems is that the variances requested based on the current presentation are not necessarily the variances that will be required once all of the proposed changes are made. Chairman Bagoff stated that he believed the best approach would be to subdivide the land and have the applicant return with the appropriate plan, including a turning template, so the Board can determine what variances are actually needed. Ms. McGovern stated that the Board's proposal would require the applicant to re-notice and return with a Planner on the variances, even though the applicant had already provided the Planner's expert testimony. Ms. McGovern stated that, if the Board wants to see the turning template, position of the house, size of the addition, size of the driveway, and placement of the parking spaces, those matters had already been covered through the Planner's expert testimony. Ms. McGovern suggested that it

Page 11

he house, size of the addition, size of the driveway, and placement of the parking spaces, those matters had already been covered through the Planner's expert testimony. Ms. McGovern suggested that it would be more efficient for the applicant to submit the revised information and have the Board vote on it at the next meeting rather than require the applicant to go through the entire noticing process again, including newspaper publication and another application. Ms. McGovern stated that requiring another application would also result in additional expense for the applicant. Mr. Klein stated that he had thought the applicant could simply carry the matter until September and provide the requested information. He noted that he believed he had asked for turning templates at the prior hearing but apparently had not. Mr. Klein stated that the building shown on the current plan might not be the size of the building the applicant ultimately wants and that the proposed addition might not be the final size or shape. He stated that the applicant would therefore need to come back with a real drawing. Chairman Bagoff stated that the Board cannot grant variances for something that may not be the final proposal, particularly where additional variances may be required. He stated that this could otherwise require the applicant to return for another application.

File revisions (1)