Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Aug 12, 2026

August 12, 2026, Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256e70fb166374efcc58fdf24a4881520d4bb1d2f20e40efa25c502122978b84f93

Indexed text · page 12

Show all pages
Page 12

Chairman Bagoff stated that, if the applicant agrees, he would support the approach suggested by Ms. McGovern: return with the appropriate turning templates and the appropriate position of the new house. Mr. Klein asked whether the variance for the front yard setback was noticed. Ms. McGovern stated that she believed it was included in the catch-all notice and indicated that she would review the notice again. Mr. Trembulak stated that if the Board wanted the new house moved forward, which he believed everyone agreed was a good plan, that would require an additional variance. He stated that, because of the catch-all notice, he was not concerned about a notice issue. Mr. Klein recalled Ms. Apti discussing that the new building had to look substantially different from the existing building, including differences in color and design, and asked who would verify compliance. Ms. McGovern stated that the zoning official would verify this and that the applicant had already testified that it would comply with the design condition. Chairman Bagoff stated that, if the application were approved, the Board's experts, the building department, and the zoning official would review the plans and the proposed addition based upon the Board's direction. Chairman Bagoff noted that the existing house had a pre-existing non-conforming condition and that, if the turning templates did not work, the applicant would have to address the issue. Mr. Klein expressed concern that the applicant could otherwise have a subdivided lot that could not be built on because parking could not be provided in the rear. Mr. Trembulak stated that they could make the turning templates work and would do what was necessary, including shrinking the addition or the proposed new house. He agreed to provide turning templates. Mr. Trembulak asked for direction from the Board regarding the location and front yard setback for the new house and the minimum driveway width for Lot 58.02. He stated that, if a variance were required, he asked that the Board grant it, after which the remaining issues could be handled by the professionals and building department during the building permit review. He stated that the review could confirm the required parking, sufficient turning templates, and related requirements. Council President Scarpa stated that she felt there was not enough information completed to make a

Page 12

e review could confirm the required parking, sufficient turning templates, and related requirements. Council President Scarpa stated that she felt there was not enough information completed to make a decision at that time because there were too many variables that could change. Chairman Bagoff stated that the Board was working through the variables and could set parameters for the experts, building department, and zoning official to use in making those decisions. Mr. Alper agreed that the Board could essentially set parameters. Mr. Klein asked whether there was a minimum driveway width and questioned why an 8- foot driveway was being proposed. Chairman Bagoff noted that the applicant was seeking a variance for the minimum driveway width. Mr. Klein stated that the driveway needed to be adequate because two sets of families would be sharing it and that it could not be a substandard width. Mr. Trembulak stated that 14 feet seemed excessive for a driveway. Mr. Klein clarified that the 14 feet was not the driveway width. He stated that the driveway appeared to be approximately 10 feet wide, with approximately 2 feet on cither side within the 14-foot area from the building to the property line. Mr. Klein stated that Lot 58.01 appeared to have a 10-foot setback and a 10-foot driveway, while Lot 58.02 appeared to have a 10-foot setback and an 8-foot driveway. Mr. Trembulak asked whether 10 feet would be acceptable for the driveway width. Mr. Klein stated yes

File revisions (1)