Minutes · Aug 12, 2026
August 12, 2026, Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes
e70fb166374efcc58fdf24a4881520d4bb1d2f20e40efa25c502122978b84f93Indexed text · page 31
Show all pagesMs. Keller stated that Purpose I, promoting a desirable visual environment, would also be advanced. She described the project as exciting in terms of its purpose, design, and other features. Ms. Keller stated that the proposal would constitute infill development with continuous building frontage and would incorporate elements identified in the Master Plan. She also noted that the project would promote renewable energy through solar panels and other design features previously addressed by the architect. Regarding the negative criteria, Ms. Keller stated that she did not see any substantial detriment to the public good associated with the requested variances. She noted enhanced safety features around the site and stated that the proposal was consistent with the intended purpose of corner lots under the Master Plan and zoning. Ms. Keller stated that the building was not excessively high, did not require additional building setbacks or building-height relief, and that the massing was appropriate. She described the proposal as an exceptional use of the corner site within the retail environment. Ms. Keller stated that the loading and off-street parking variances tepresented a better planning alternative, in her opinion. Regarding substantial impairment to the zone plan, Ms. Keller stated that the applicant had reviewed the 2019 Master Plan update and believed the proposal was consistent with what the Township was seeking when the Master Plan was prepared. Ms. Keller noted that the 2019 Master Plan specifically recommended flexibility in downtown parking ratios. She stated that, although the ordinance had not been changed, the recommendation was indicative of the importance of balancing uses and parking in downtown sites. Ms. Keller identified the incorporation of green infrastructure, maintaining a balance of land uses including non-residential uses in downtown core areas, streetscape and parking improvements, and making West Orange more environmentally and economically sustainable through a mix of land uses as objectives supported by the proposal. Ms. Keller stated that the proposal also continued longstanding Master Plan objectives concerning development, redevelopment, and rehabilitation of the Main Street Central Business District. Ms. Keller stated that the Master Plan focused on ensuring continued investment and improvements to the downtown and Main
development, and rehabilitation of the Main Street Central Business District. Ms. Keller stated that the Master Plan focused on ensuring continued investment and improvements to the downtown and Main Street corridor. She concluded that the proposed development was consistent with the Master Plan, would not substantially impair the zoning ordinance or zone plan, and that the positive and negative criteria had been satisfied and the requested relief could be granted. Ms. Wolfe asked Ms. Keller to address the requested waivers. Ms. Keller initially understood the question to concern checklist waivers and indicated that she would defer to engineering or counsel regarding those items. Ms. Wolfe identified the illumination waivers, including illumination levels at the pedestrian walkway. Ms. Keller stated that the proposed illumination level at the pedestrian walkway was 5 foot-candles, where 0.9 is required, and referred to the engineer’s testimony that the requirement could be addressed as part of resolution compliance if the application were approved. Ms. Keller stated that light levels at the property line abutting residential uses were proposed at 0.5 foot-candles, where a maximum of 0.3 foot-candles is permitted. She stated that, given the context of the site and the existing conditions, the waiver was reasonable. 31
File revisions (1)
- Nov 3, 2026
e70fb166374e25,949,455 bytes