Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Aug 12, 2026

August 12, 2026, Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256e70fb166374efcc58fdf24a4881520d4bb1d2f20e40efa25c502122978b84f93

Indexed text · page 9

Show all pages
Page 9

PUBLIC QUESTIONS Kevin Malanga asked whether the applicant is presently the occupant of the house in question. Mr. Trembulak stated that his client lives there when he is in town and also spends time in Virginia, to the best of his understanding. He stated that when Mr. Perez is in New Jersey, he stays at the house. Mr. Malanga asked whether the property is not currently Mr. Perez's primary residence. Mr. Trembulak stated that his understanding is that it is not currently his primary residence, but that Mr. Perez plans to relocate back to New Jersey, at which point the property would become his primary residence. Mr. Malanga asked Mr. Flynn what planning goals sought to be advanced when the Township established the lot widths applicable to the street. Mr. Flynn stated that the reason behind dimensional variances is usually to ensure consistency among properties, so that one property is not excessively narrow or small compared with the rest. Mr. Flynn stated that, when considering the intent behind the requirement, including neighborhood consistency, adequate light, air, open space, and building separation, he believed all of those intents are met by the proposal. Mr. Malanga asked whether those purposes were met by the establishment of the current lot width requirement. Mr. Flynn stated that he believed they were being met by the proposal. Mr-Malanga clarified that he was asking what the Township sought to accomplish when it established the current lot widths. Mr. Flynn stated that one of the intents behind those requirements is consistency between properties so that something docs not stand out in the context of the area, as well as concerns about building separation and density. Mr. Malanga asked whether Mr. Flynn was seeking to subvert the intention of the zoning by establishing the lot width that the applicant is seeking to overcome. Mr. Flynn stated that, given the neighborhood, the consistency of the proposed lot width makes it appropriate for this particular property. Mr. Malanga asked whether Mr. Flynn had calculated how many lots meet the current zoning-required width versus the number that do not. Mr. Trembulak asked what area Mr. Malanga was referring to. Mr. Malanga stated that he was referring to the neighborhood identified by Mr. Flynn. Mr. Flynn returned to his planning exhibit and stated that, when considering neighborhood

Page 9

alanga was referring to. Mr. Malanga stated that he was referring to the neighborhood identified by Mr. Flynn. Mr. Flynn returned to his planning exhibit and stated that, when considering neighborhood compatibility, he starts with the block itself because those are the most immediately surrounding properties. He stated that he sometimes looks farther out, but in this case believed the point was clear by focusing on the particular block. o Mr. Flynn stated that, on the block, there are several properties developed with two-family dwellings that have 50-foot lot widths or smaller, as well as three- family properties on similarly sized lots. Mr. Malanga stated that Mr. Flynn had not provided the Board with a numerical calculation comparing those properties to the total number of lots on the block. Mr. Flynn asked whether Mr. Malanga was referring to the total number of lots in the town. Mr. Malanga clarified that he was referring to the one block because Mr. Flynn based his opinion on that block and asked what percentage complies and what percentage does not comply. Mr. Trembulak objected to the question and stated that the calculation could be made by counting the lots. o Mr. Flynn stated that he disagreed that such a calculation was necessarily required to determine whether something is consistent. He stated that when walking down a street, a person is not doing math in their head but is considering what is apparent. He stated that this was the intention behind the way he prepared his analysis.

File revisions (1)