Minutes · Sep 2, 2026
September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes
c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7Indexed text
le Rock Avenue. 0 ‘Mr. Schkolnick explained that the July 1, 2026 hearing included extensive cross- ‘oly 20 examination of Mr: Penke, followed by approximately 20 minutes of testimony from Mr. Cote regarding the civil engineering plans. o He stated that the current hearing would continue with cross-examination of Mr. Cote, followed by testimony from the applicant's planner as the final witness. BOARD QUESTIONS Ms. Kapferer referred to the April 24, 2026 Artheon review letter, which included comments concerning the geotechnical report and the depth to seasonal high groundwater. She asked whether additional testing had been performed, noting a potential conflict between the seasonal high groundwater elevation and the bottom of the proposed stormwater basin. Mr. Cote explained that testing had been performed at or near both proposed basins to evaluate seasonal high groundwater conditions. He also stated that the site contained Class D soils, which do not permit adequate infiltration.
- Mr. Cote explained that because of the Class D soils, the proposed bioretention basins would filter stormwater through the bioretention media and then discharge the treated water through an outlet rather than infiltrating it into the ground. Ms. Kapferer asked specifically whether the concern regarding seasonal high groundwater being higher than the bottom of the basin had been resolved. Mr. Cote stated that, to his knowledge, the issue had been resolved through the geotechnical review. He also confirmed that the applicant would address the comments and provide responses as part of the review process. PROFESSIONAL QUESTIONS Ms.:Apteasked Mr. Cote:to confirm that he had received and reviewed the planning review detterdated June 3, 2026, and that the applicant agreed to comply with the comments contained inthe letter. Mr. Cote confirmed that the applicant would comply. Mr:-Valesirasked Mr. Cote'whether the applicant had reviewed the engineering report and agreed to comply with all comments. Mr. Cote confirmed that the applicant would comply with the report. PUBLIC QUESTIONS “Mr. Joe Panullolof Holton Lane, Essex Fells, asked whether any portion of the site, (proposed modifications, or stormwater runoff was located within a Water Quality Management Plan area. Mr. Cote explained that the entire site, along with the Township, is included within the Water Quality Management Plan for purposes of public sanitary | ssewer'service. He Clarified that stormwater management is governed by applicable NJDEP and Township regulations. Mr. Panullo:asked:whéther the Water Quality Management Plan covered a broader area beyond the subjevt:property.'Mr. Cote confirmed that the plan was not limited to the site Mi Panullo also asked whether the property was located within a watershed, and Mr. Cote confirmed that it was. Mr! Panullo asked whether arty NJDEP permits were required, submitted, or anticipated for the project. Mr. Cote stated that no NJDEP permits were required because the proposed improvements would not disturb any areas under NJDEP jurisdiction. Mr. Panullo asked: about the direction of stormwater runoff from the site. Mr. Cote explained that a watershed divide runs approximately through the middle of the project. Stormwater from one portion 6f the site flows toward the Eagle Rock Avenue and Laurel ‘Avenue intersection, while stormwater from the other
divide runs approximately through the middle of the project. Stormwater from one portion 6f the site flows toward the Eagle Rock Avenue and Laurel ‘Avenue intersection, while stormwater from the other portion flows east along Eagle Rock Avenue into the existing County roadway drainage system. Mr. Panullo asked whether any stormwater would flow north across Eagle Rock Avenue toward the golf course and Pleasantdale Chateau. Mr. Cote stated that the project's stormwater flows east and west through the existing conveyance systems and does not flow north toward those properties. Mr, Panullo asked how water flowing toward Canoe Brook and across Laurel Avenue or Eagle Rock Avenue would be handled. Mr. Cote explained that the project addresses existing sheet flow from the site, which currently drains downhill toward Eagle Rock Avenue without detention. He stated that the applicant is proposing stormwater detention facilities to control and slow the runoff. Mr. Panullo questioned how stormwater from the elevated parking lot and country club property could flow east and west rather than north. Mr. Cote explained that the crown of Eagle Rock Avenue creates an east-west distribution of water, similar to the peak of a gabled roof, with runoff flowing in opposite directions from the high point.
Mr. Panullo asked where the proposed driveway would be located in relation to the high point of the roadway. Mr. Cote explained that the proposed four-way intersection at Oval Road would be located just east of the peak where stormwater flows divide east and west. Mr. Panullo asked about the sidewalk requested by the Board during the previous hearing and whether it would be installed on both sides of the proposed driveway. Mr. Cote clarified that the sidewalk was requested along the Crestmont Country Club side of Eagle Rock:Avenue;:extending to both the left and right of the proposed driveway. He stated that the sidewalk would be located along Eagle Rock Avenue and would not extend along Laurel Avenue or into the interior of the property. Mr:Panullo'asked whether the sidewalk would increase the grade or slope of the property. Mr. Cote explained that the sidewalk had been incorporated into the ‘approximately 10-foot-wide clear area proposed alongside the widened roadway. He stated that:the sidewalk would be installed within that relatively flat area and would not require changes to the existing site grades. Mr: Panullo asked whether Mr. Cote's testimony was limited to stormwater management. Mr::Gote clarified that his responsibilities included site civil engineering, drainage, and site layout design). but not the traffic engineering elements of the application. Dr. Deborah Buteisky of 11 Rapley Court asked Mr. Cote to repeat the grade of the proposed new driveway:\Mr: ‘Cote stated that the driveway would have an approximately 8.5% gradé along its main portion, transitioning to approximately 5% at the Eagle Rock Avenue intersection and approximately 3% near the upper parking lot Dr Butensky asked about 'the'speed limit on the proposed driveway. Mr. Cote explained that thé driveway would be.an internal driveway without a posted speed limit, although approximately 15. miles per hour would be typical for that type of driveway. DrButensky asked*hdw' converting the existing T-intersection at Oval Road and Eagle RockiAvenue.into a four-way intersection would affect the safety of drivers exiting Oval Road and traiicling:east or west. Mr. Cote stated that the applicant's traffic engineer had previously testifidd regarding the additional safety improvements associated with the proposed intersection: He explained that the detailed traffic analysis was outside
pplicant's traffic engineer had previously testifidd regarding the additional safety improvements associated with the proposed intersection: He explained that the detailed traffic analysis was outside the scope of his civil engineering testimony. , ‘Dr. Butensky askethwhy the existing driveway needed to be relocated. Mr. Cote explained’ that the current driveway intersects Eagle Rock Avenue at a sharp angle, making left-hand turns difficult because drivers must turn their heads more than 90 degrees to, observe oncoming traffic. He stated that the proposed driveway would intersect Eagle Rock Avenue perpendicularly, providing improved sightlines and allowing vehicles to enter and exit through a signalized intersection. Dr. Butensky asked how the new driveway would affect sightlines for drivers traveling eastbound on Eagle Rock Avenue from Laurel Avenue. Mr. Cote stated that the proposed improvements would not negatively affect those drivers. He explained that widening Eagle Rock Avenue, providing an additional left-turn lane, and clearing an approximately 10-foot-wide area alongside the roadway would improve visibility and the sight triangle at the intersection. Dr. Butensky requested further clarification regarding the proposed left-turn lane into Oval Road. Mr. Cote explained that vehicles traveling along Eagle Rock Avenue toward Oval Road would have a designated left-turn lane, allowing turning vehicles to move outside the through lanes. He stated that the additional lane would reduce interference with through traffic and improve the existing roadway conditions. Dr. Butensky asked what proof the applicant had that the proposed intersection would not create additional traffic accidents. Mr. Cote stated that the applicant's traffic engineer had already provided testimony and supporting documentation addressing the proposed safety 9
improvements and that those materials had been reviewed by the Township. He reiterated that his role was to respond to questions concerning civil engineering and site design rather than repeat the traffic engineer's testimony. Dr. Butensky asked for clarification on how the proposed driveway of approximately 8% grade couldn’t be dangerous during winter conditions. Mr. Cote explained that an 8% grade is acceptable under applicable standards and that certain standards could permit grades of up to 12%. Mr. Paul Tractenberg of 96 Sullivan Drive, referred to a March 17, 2026 letter from Mr. Schkolnick to the Planning Board Secretary and the Planning Board. He stated that the ; letter identified several items for which the applicant was seeking relief from Township ordinance requirements governing the R2 zone. Mr. Tractenberg first questioned the proposed retaining wall height, noting that the ordinance permits a'maximum height of 4 feet while the applicant proposes a retaining hwall:approximately 21.5.feet high, more than five times the permitted height. He asked Mr: \Gote:to.explain the justification for such a substantial deviation. Mr. Cote explained that the proposed retaining wall is located in conjunction with the stormwater simanagement basin required to attenuate runoff from the site. He stated that the wall height'is necessary to accommodate the stormwater management infrastructure while maintaining reasonable grades in the upper parking lot. Mri Tractenbergnext questioned the minimum setback from the top of steep slopes having grades between 10% and 30%. He stated that the ordinance requires a 50-foot setback whilethe applicant proposes a 10-foot setback. He asked whether this reduction wouldicreate any:safety concerns. Mr. Cote stated that he did not believe the proposed setback would create'a safety issue. He explained that the design was intended to minimiizeidisturbance to the property and avoid removing additional trees. He stated that providing the fulb setback would require further tree removal and that the applicant had : beenidirected to minimize impacts on existing trees while providing replacement plantings for disturbed areas. Mr. Tractenberg also questioned the applicant's request for a site plan waiver concerning ‘:tree removal on:slopes of 10% or greater. He stated that the application proposes temoving 191 trees located on
ractenberg also questioned the applicant's request for a site plan waiver concerning ‘:tree removal on:slopes of 10% or greater. He stated that the application proposes temoving 191 trees located on slopes of 10% or greater. Mr. Cote confirmed that the number was accurate. Mr. Tractenberg asked whether Mr. Cote believed that the proposed tree removal was justified. Mr. Cote stated that the removals were associated with the positioning of the proposed improvements, the need to connect the site improvements to existing grades, and the installation of drainage structures necessary to mitigate stormwater runoff and improve drainage along Eagle Rock Avenue. He explained that the affected portions of the property are located near Eagle Rock Avenue and within areas having slopes of 10% or greater. Mr. Tractenberg next questioned the minimum setback from the top of steep slopes exceeding 30%. He stated that the ordinance requires a 100-foot setback while the applicant proposes a 10-foot setback. Mr. Cote confirmed that the proposed reduction was justified for the same reasons previously discussed, including minimizing disturbance and accommodating the proposed infrastructure and site improvements. Mr. Tractenberg questioned whether all of the requested ordinance deviations were being sought to add parking spaces and reconfigure the exit from a private country club. He referred to 36 additional parking spaces and stated that the existing parking lot was already hundreds of spaces short of the ordinance requirement. Mr. Cote confirmed that the requested deviations were associated with the parking and driveway improvements
Mr. Kevin Malanga of Ridge Road asked Mr. Cote whether a complete and accurate survey of trees proposed for removal was required for the project. Mr. Cote confirmed that a tree survey had already been completed and that the trees proposed for removal were identified on the submitted plans. Mr. Malanga asked whether the applicant had agreed to construct a sidewalk along Eagle Rock Avenue from Laurel Avenue eastward to the end of the Crestmont Country Club property. Mr. Cote confirmed that this was correct. Mr. Malanga asked whether a tree removal survey had been prepared for the proposed sidewalk and whether those trees were included in the applicant's tree removal calculations: Mr: Gote explained that the sidewalk would be constructed within the area of disturbance already included in the original design and that all affected trees had already been accounted for. He confirmed that the sidewalk would not require the removal of any additional trees. Mr. Malanga asketl whether the proposed sidewalk would comply with the Americans withDisabilities Act. Mr! Cote stated that the sidewalk would comply with the Public Right-of-Way Accessibility Guidelines (PROWAG), which establish accessibility requirements for pedestrian facilities within public roadways. Mr«Malanga asked whither the applicant had surveyed the property to confirm that the sidewalk could:be constructed in compliance with those requirements. Mr. Cote confirmed yes Mr. Malanga asked whether that determination had been made before the Board requested: the sidewalk at the previous hearing. Mr. Cote explained that the sidewalk had not originally been anticipated, but the grades and clear areas established through the original survey and site designiwere sufficient to incorporate it without requiring changes to the proposed grading. Mr, Malanga asked whether the applicant understood that it would be responsible for maintaining the sidewalk, including snow removal. Mr. Cote stated that it was his understanding that the applicant would be responsible. ©. Mr. S¢hkolnick clarified that the sidewalk maintenance responsibilities had not yet been finalized. oy «Mr. Cote explained that Eagle Rock Avenue is a County road and that inainfenance responsibilities would ultimately depend on the agreements reached with the County. Mr, Malanga again asked whether the applicant would be responsible for snow removal and
y road and that inainfenance responsibilities would ultimately depend on the agreements reached with the County. Mr, Malanga again asked whether the applicant would be responsible for snow removal and sidewalk:maintenance. Mr. Cote reiterated that he understood the applicant would be responsible, although he could not provide a definitive answer until the agreements with the County were completed. He stated that he did not anticipate a reason why the applicant would not be responsible. Mr. Malanga asked Mr. Cote whether any retaining walls would need to be constructed for the proposed sidewalk along Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote explained that a retaining wall was already included as part of the original roadway widening and that no additional retaining walls would be required for the sidewalk. Mr. Victor Misarti of Mayfair Drive, referred to two site plan review letters available on the Planning Board agenda. He first referenced an April 2026 review letter from Planning Board Engineer Ryan McNeil, which included comments regarding design, stormwater management, landscaping, and additional information required from the applicant. Mr. Misarti asked whether the applicant intended to revise and resubmit the site plans to address those comments, noting that he had not seen revised plans submitted since the review. Mr. Cote confirmed that the applicant had agreed to address the questions and comments contained in the review letters and that a resubmission would be required.
o Mr. Schkolnick clarified that addressing those comments would be a matter of resolution compliance. Mr. Misarti also referenced Ms. Apte's June 2026 planning review letter, which contained comments regarding landscaping, trees, fences, additional information, approvals from other agencies, and required variances. He asked whether those comments would also be incorporated into the revised site plans. Mr. Cote confirmed that the applicant had agreed to address Ms. Apte's comments as part of resolution compliance. Ms: Micaela Bennett of Old Indian Road asked Mr. Cote to explain what existing condition or.erigineering deficiency made the proposed new traffic signal necessary. Mr. Cote explained that the’ traffic-related safety elements had already been addressed through'testimony from the applicant's traffic engineer. He stated that, from a civil engineering standpoint, the project would improve existing drainage conditions along Eagle Rock Avenue. Ms. Bennett asked how much additional impervious surface would be created by the proposed driveivay, parking, and roadway improvements. Mr. Cote stated that the project »ewould create approximately 12,000 square feet of additional impervious surface on-site, ) ‘slightly: mote than one-quarter acre, and approximately 9,900 square feet of additional impervious surface off-site along Eagle Rock Avenue. He stated that the total additional impervious surface would be approximately one-half acre. Msv:Bennett requested the-existing and proposed stormwater runoff rates for the 2-year, 10-year, 25-year,.and 100-year storm events. Mr. Cote explained that the stormwater panalysis was divided into two areas, with one discharge point near the intersection of Eagle Rock Avenue aid Laurel Avenue and the other at the eastern end of the site. He stated that the calculations considered both current storm events and future storm events based on projécted conditions for the year 2100. Mr. Cote provided the following existing and proposed peak fldw:rates for Point of Analysis 1, located near Eagle Rock Avenue and Laurel Avenue, under current storm conditions: 0. 2+yéar storm:/13.48 cubic fect per second (CFS) existing and 11.32 CFS proposed. o 10-year storm: 23.47 CFS existing and 19.76 CFS proposed. ©, 100-year storm: 44.56 CFS existing and 38.87 CFS proposed. Mr. Cote provided the following rates for Point of Analysis 1 under future
File revisions (1)
- Nov 6, 2026
c1f7e551165725,244,207 bytes