Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Sep 2, 2026

September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7

Indexed text

Page 17

d professionals would therefore not be addressed before the Board made its decision. Mr. Cote explained that'a majority of the items had already been addressed through testimony and that the #emaining technical comments would be addressed through revisions associated with resolution compliance, along with any additional requests from the Board, including the proposed sidewalk. Mr. Panullo asked whether sidewalks were proposed along the driveway leading into Crestmont Country Club or whether the driveway would consist only of roadway lanes. Mr. Cote confirmed that no sidewalks were proposed along the driveway. Mr. Panullo referred to previous discussions with Ms. Dana Cancellaro and testimony from Mr. Penke regarding the possibility of accommodating a bus stop near the country club. He asked whether a bus stop was included in the plans. Mr. Cote stated that the bus stop had been addressed in Mr. Penke's traffic testimony and was not part of his civil engineering testimony. Mr. Panullo asked how employees or other individuals using a potential bus stop along Eagle Rock Avenue would walk to the country club if the driveway did not include a sidewalk or steps. He also questioned what grade pedestrians would encounter. Mr. Cote explained that the proposed driveway was intended for vehicles exiting the country club only and that pedestrian access from a potential bus stop was an operational issue. He stated that he was not certain how the club would address that situation.

Page 18

Mr. Panullo asked whether pedestrian access along the driveway was included in the current plans, and Mr. Cote confirmed that it was not. Mr. Panullo asked whether the proposed design included any measures to capture or manage stormwater at the upper parking lot before it flowed downhill toward the detention basins. Mr. Cote explained that the upper parking lot would include porous pavement as a water quality measure. He stated that porous pavement is an allowable stormwater treatment method under current standards and would help achieve the project's overall water quality goals. ‘MrpPanullo asked whether water would be contained at the upper parking lot. Mr. Cote clarified that the porous pavement would allow stormwater to pass through and be filtered rather than function as the primary detention system. He explained that the detention basins would be located farther downhill. Mr:Pamullo asked whether the proposed roadway widening, retaining walls, and sidewalk would affect! the time of concentration or velocity of stormwater runoff from the site. Mr. Cote‘explained that the existing and proposed times of concentration and the manner in whichistormwater moves acrdss the site were included in the stormwater calculations. He stated thatithose factors were considered in designing the proposed stormwater management:system to comply with the Township's stormwater management requirements. Mr. Panullo;asked.whether the applicant was representing that the proposed design complied with iheTownship's stormwater ordinance. Mr. Cote confirmed that it did. Mri:Panullo also asked whether the flow rates were included in the compliance calculations; and'Mr, Cote coi firmed that the previously stated flow rates complied with the applicable requirements. PRESENTATION | The professional planner, Mr: Sean Moronski, entered on the record and was sworn under oath. He testified to the following: Mr.Schkolnick:asked Mr. Moronski to address the proposed site improvements and the requested varidinces.Mr. Moronski confirmed that he had reviewed the plans, application materials; professional reports, review letters, and the site. He also stated that he had heard, the-testimony fromthe current and two previous hearings, including questions from the Board's professionals, Board members, and the public. Mr: Moronski explainedsthat his testimony would address each requested C or

Page 18

omthe current and two previous hearings, including questions from the Board's professionals, Board members, and the public. Mr: Moronski explainedsthat his testimony would address each requested C or bulk variarice and demonstrate how the application satisfied the standards for relief under the Municipal Land Use Law. Mr. Moronski first addressed Section 25-12.1.B, which requires a minimum distance of 5 feet from the parking area curb to fencing, screening, or a structure. He stated that setbacks of less than 5 feet already existed in various locations and that the applicant proposed a 3-foot setback. Mr. Moronski stated that the applicant was requesting relief under the C2 variance criteria, where the overall benefits of the application outweigh the concerns associated with the deviation. He explained that the reduced setback would allow the parking area to reconnect with the proposed driveway grading and retaining wall. Mr. Moronski stated that the deviation would affect six parking spaces and represented a very minor impact. He explained that the reduced setback would not affect neighboring buildings or uses and would not create the types of concerns typically associated with parking areas near neighboring properties, such as vehicle lights or activity.

Page 19

Mr. Moronski explained that the proposed 3-foot setback would allow a guardrail and fence to be installed along the eastern side of the proposed parking area adjacent to the modular building. He stated that these protective measures would address safety concerns for vehicular and pedestrian circulation along the retaining wall. Mr. Moronski next addressed Section 25-12.2.B.1, concerning the minimum number of required parking spaces. He.explained that the golf clubhouse is a permitted principal use and is classified asia private club for parking calculations. The ordinance requires one ) parking space for every 45 square feet of gross floor area. Mr)Moronski stated that the ordinance calculation requires 700 parking spaces for the facility, while 256 spaces currently exist, representing an existing nonconforming condition. He stated that the applicant proposes 292 spaces, including electric vehicle parking credits under which four electric vehicle spaces are counted as two spaces each. Mr. Moronskirexplained that the applicant was seeking a C2 variance for the parking requirement. He stated that the driveway reconfiguration would create an opportunity to providevadditional parking abthe upper level, closer to the main country club facility, to support activities at Crestmont Country Club. Mr. Moronski stated:that:the proposal would increase the number of parking spaces by 36, reducing the existing: parking deficiency. He described the ordinance requirement of 700 spaces as‘excessive for the country club's actual needs and the nature of the site. He .cexplained that providing that number of spaces was neither necessary nor desirable, particularly given the applicant's efforts to minimize disturbance to the property. Mr. Moronski:stated that, under the C2 criteria, the additional parking spaces would improve the existirg nonconforming condition and represent an overall enhancement to the property. Mr. Moronski next addressed the maximum retaining wall height variance. He stated that the ordinance:permits retaining walls up to 4 feet in height, while the proposed improvements 'include'more than 1,300 linear feet of retaining walls, with a maximum height of approximately 21.5 feet. Mr: Moronski‘explained that the maximum wall height occurs near the stormwater management basin:and js necessary to maintain the elevation of the upper parking lot. He statdd that

Page 19

oximately 21.5 feet. Mr: Moronski‘explained that the maximum wall height occurs near the stormwater management basin:and js necessary to maintain the elevation of the upper parking lot. He statdd that the requested variance could be granted under the C1 criteria, specifically CIB, because of the exceptional topographic conditions of the property. Mr. Moronski stated: that the proposed retaining wall heights are necessary to overcome the site's existing topography: He explained that attempting to meet the 4-foot maximum would:réequiréa:greater number of retaining walls, additional site disturbance, and potentially the removal of more trees. Mr. Moronski stated that the proposed design was intended to strike a balance between minimizing disturbance and addressing drainage and roadway improvement needs. He explained that the retaining walls would help limit the amount of land disturbance and tree removal while accommodating the stormwater improvements and the new driveway. Mr. Moronski stated that the elevation at the proposed signalized intersection on Eagle Rock Avenue is approximately 538, while the existing and proposed upper parking areas range from elevations 557 to 565. He explained that the parking areas are approximately 20 to 30 feet higher than the roadway, creating the need for taller retaining walls to accommodate the grade difference while minimizing disturbance. Mr. Moronski stated that the retaining walls would help create the new exit driveway and intersection along Eagle Rock Avenue, which he described as a significant safety improvement over the existing condition. Mr. Moronski next addressed the requested variances related to the Township's topographic and steep slope requirements. He stated that the variances were

Page 20

interconnected and were being requested because of the site's exceptional topographic conditions. Mr. Moronski explained that the ordinance requires a minimum setback of 50 feet from the top of steep slopes having grades between 10% and 30%. He stated that the relocated driveway and proposed parking spaces would be located within 10 feet of the top of those slopes. Mr. Moronski stated that the ordinance also requires a minimum setback of 100 feet from the top of steep slopes greater than 30%. He explained that the relocated driveway and parking spaces would likewise be located within 10 feet of those slopes. Mr. Moronski'stated that the; Township ordinance does not permit disturbance of slopes » greater than 25%. He explained that the applicant proposes disturbing approximately 10.9% of the property's slopesexceeding 25%, representing approximately 0.38 acres, or 16,400-square feét; out of more than 150,000 square feet of slopes greater than 25%. Mr. Moronskialso:addressed the maximum driveway slope. He stated that existing driveway slopes of up to approximately 10.5% near Laurel Avenue would remain, while the proposed driveway would have a slope of approximately 8.5%. ‘Mr. Moronski stated thatthe requested steep slope and driveway variances were justified »nunder the C1B criteria because of the property's exceptional topographic conditions. He explained that grading activities on the site necessarily result in some steep slope disturbance and:that the proposed design attempts to integrate the improvements into the existing landscape white minimizing disturbance and tree removal to the extent feasible. Mr:'Moronski reiterated thai the proposed improvements would be located within 10 feet of certain'steep:slopés where a 50-foot sctback is otherwise required and stated that the same C1B justification applied. ‘Mr.Moronski explained that the requested relief would advance several purposes of the Municipal Land;Use,Law; beginning with Purpose A, which encourages appropriate use and development of.land to promote public health, safety, and general welfare. ‘Mro‘Moronski stated that‘the proposed improvements would provide safety, circulation, and aesthetic benefits along Eagle Rock Avenue, as well as stormwater management \ improvements that would benefit both the site and the surrounding roadway. Mrs Moronski next addressed Purpose D of the

Page 20

aesthetic benefits along Eagle Rock Avenue, as well as stormwater management \ improvements that would benefit both the site and the surrounding roadway. Mrs Moronski next addressed Purpose D of the Municipal Land Use Law, which seeks to ensure that development within one municipality does not conflict with the development and general welfare of neighboring municipalities. \Mre Moronski stated that ‘West Orange, Essex County, and the neighboring municipalities of Roseland-and Essex Fells would benefit from the proposed improvements. He identified the traffic signal, driveway reconfiguration, Eagle Rock Avenue improvements, drainage improvements, and improved sight triangles as benefits extending beyond the country club property. Mr. Moronski next addressed Purpose H, which encourages the location and design of transportation routes that promote the free flow of traffic while discouraging congestion or blight. Mr. Moronski stated that relocating the country club driveway would reduce points of conflict along Eagle Rock Avenue and align the driveway with Oval Road to create a four-leg intersection. He explained that the associated roadway widening would improve safety at the intersection by allowing vehicles making left turns to queue separately from the eastbound through lane. Mr. Moronski addressed Purpose I of the Municipal Land Use Law, which promotes a desirable visual environment through creative design techniques and good civic design. He stated that the tree replacement throughout the site, the proposed site improvements, 20

Page 21

and the enhanced aesthetics along the Eagle Rock Avenue frontage would provide both on-site and public benefits from an aesthetic perspective. Mr. Moronski next addressed Purpose M, which encourages coordination of public and private procedures and activities shaping land development to lessen development costs and promote more efficient use of land. He stated that the applicant had worked with Essex County to provide land along the Eagle Rock Avenue frontage for roadway improvements. Mr. Moronski‘explained that the proposed driveway realignment would create an intersection and éliminate a driveway that otherwise would not align with the intersection across Eagle Rock Avenue» He stated that this represented an overall public benefit and emphasized that applications must be evaluated not only for the benefits to the applicant but also for the benefits to the public. Mr:'Moronski addressed:the negative criteria for the requested variances, stating that thiéreawould be no substantial detriment to the public good. He explained that every applicatioinmay' have some impact, but the question is whether that impact rises to the devel of being substantial and, if so, whether it is being addressed. Mr. Moronski stated that ssex County was favorable toward the proposed intersection improverhents:and driyeway relocation, which had been suggested by the County traffic etigineer years earlier: He identified the widening of Eagle Rock Avenue, the proposed lefi-turn lane onto Oval: Road, the lengthening of the left-turn lane onto Laurel Avenue, coordiiation with the Laurel Avenue traffic signal, and improved sight distances as benefits of the application. »Mri:Moronski stated thatthe project would improve stormwater management and benefit the’ surrounding:area. He explained that the existing driveway drains water onto Eagle Rock Avenue-and:that removal of the driveway, together with the proposed drainage intprovements along Eagle Rock Avenue, would help remedy that condition. Mr. Motonski-also addressed the sidewalk recommended by the Planning Board, which would extend along Eagle Rock Avenue from Laurel Avenue to the end of the Crestmont property line,'but not-onto any other property. He stated that the sidewalk would enhance the potential for pedestrian activity. Mr. Moronskiemphasized that the proposed site improvements would not increase the Lintensity of the

Page 21

y other property. He stated that the sidewalk would enhance the potential for pedestrian activity. Mr. Moronskiemphasized that the proposed site improvements would not increase the Lintensity of the country’ club's use. He stated that no new buildings were proposed and that the application was ‘intended to improve the existing parking situation rather than increase the intensity of activity on the property. .. Mr. Moronski'stated that the tree replacement plan would contribute to the aesthetic improvements and was documented in the submitted plans. He also stated that no NJDEP permits were required for the project. Mr. Moronski referred to Mr. Cote's testimony that the proposed driveway grade of approximately 8% was acceptable under winter conditions. He noted that other existing areas of the site, including the area near Laurel Avenue, have steeper grades. Mr. Moronski stated that the stormwater detention system was required in connection with the Eagle Rock Avenue improvements. He also confirmed that the applicant had agreed to maintain the proposed sidewalk along Eagle Rock Avenue as a condition of approval and that the sidewalk had already been accounted for in the retaining wall design. Mr. Moronski stated that the proposed impervious coverage included approximately 12,000 square feet on-site, or roughly one-quarter acre, and another approximately one- quarter acre off-site. Mr. Moronski explained that the project area was approximately 3.95 acres within the overall 146-acre Crestmont Country Club property. He stated that the improvements were 21

Page 22

concentrated in a relatively small portion of the property and would provide substantial beneficial impacts. Mr. Moronski stated that the requested variances would not substantially impair the intent and purpose of the zone plan or zoning ordinance. He explained that the country club is a permitted use in the R2 zone and that the applicant was increasing the number of parking spaces while attempting to minimize disturbance. Mr. Moronski acknowledged that the proposed parking would remain well below the 700 spaces required by the ordinance but stated that the applicant was moving in the direction of improving the existing condition. He also identified the proposed sidewalk as providing additional pedestrian connectivity. Mr. Moronskireferted to. the Township's 2019 Master Plan Update, specifically Purpose 8-on page 8, whiclvaddresses providing safe and efficient transportation and circulation routes: He stated: that the objective remained relevant and included transportation modes beyond motor vehicles. Mr. Moronski stated: that West Orange had taken actions to promote pedestrian and bicyclistssafety.-Although' those efforts might not be specific to this location, he explained that the overalli Township objective was to provide options for circulation and improve safety. Mr).Movonskivalso referred to Purpose 15 on page 10 of the 2019 Master Plan Update, concerning coordination of public and private procedures and activities. He stated that this objective was:consistent with Purpose M of the Municipal Land Use Law. ‘Mr. Moronski addressed the requested site plan waiver relating to tree removal. He explained that the Planning Board may grant reasonable exceptions consistent with the general purpose and intent of the site plan ordinance. ‘Mr.\Moronski stated that the applicant proposed removing 191 trees located on slopes greater tham 0%. He explained that the justification for the waiver was similar to the justificatiorr forthe steep slope and retaining wall variances because the proposed disturbance was driven by the site's topographic conditions. Mr. Moronski stated that the overall project would remove 313 trees and that the tree replacement plan proposed well over 500 replacement trees, most of which would be planted on-site: He-explained that the tree restoration plan was included in the site plan drawings. Mr. Moronski stated that the applicant

File revisions (1)