Minutes · Sep 2, 2026
September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes
c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7Indexed text
sed well over 500 replacement trees, most of which would be planted on-site: He-explained that the tree restoration plan was included in the site plan drawings. Mr. Moronski stated that the applicant would coordinate with the Township Forester and other Township professionals to satisfy the intent of the tree replacement ordinance. MryMoronski concluded that the requested variances could be granted under the applicable C2 criteria and, for the steep slope and retaining wall variances, the C1B criteria. He stated that the requested site plan waiver was justified by the steep slope and topographic conditions and the effort to minimize disturbance while providing the proposed improvements. Mr. Schkolnick asked Mr. Moronski whether he saw any negative impacts on the immediate neighboring properties, noting that several members of the public who had spoken lived in Essex Fells or other surrounding areas. Mr. Moronski stated that he did not see negative impacts on surrounding properties. He explained that the previous professional testimony supported the drainage and circulation improvements and that the proposed on-site improvements would also benefit Crestmont Country Club, which he described as a long-established fixture in the community. Mr. Moronski stated that the project provided both public and private benefits. He explained that the design sought to minimize tree disturbance while addressing drainage, stormwater, and roadway improvements in coordination with Essex County. He stated 22
that the benefits would extend beyond West Orange to Roseland, Essex Fells, the surrounding community Mr. Schkolnick asked whether Purpose F of the Municipal Land Use Law, which encourages appropriate and efficient expenditure of public funds, factored into Mr. Moronski's analysis, since a private entity would be undertaking improvements involving a traffic signal. Mr. Moronski confirmed that it did. He stated that the public-private coordination between the applicant and the County represented a more efficient way of providing improvements that would benefit the property and the surrounding area. MriSchkolnick:asked/whether the settlement agreement previously discussed by Ms. Cancellaro, iricluding the possibility of eminent domain, affected Mr. Moronski's planning analysis. Mr. Moronski stated that the applicant's cooperation with the County, Township, and other involved :parties was a positive factor. He explained that this cooperation furthered public improyements and was consistent with Purpose M of the Municipal Land Use Law. Mr: Schkolnick again asked whether Mr. Moronski saw any negative impacts on surrounding properties. Mr. Moronski stated that he did not and reiterated that the > application would not cause a substantial detriment to the public good or substantial impairment of the zone plan or zoning ordinance. Mr. Schkolnick/asked how Mr. Penke's testimony regarding safety improvements factored into Mr. Moronski's planning analysis. Mri Moronski stated that the safety, circulation, drainage, and physical improvements, both on-site arid along Eagle Rock Avenue, worked together. He stated that, from a planning perspective, the improvements satisfied the applicable Municipal Land Use Law criteria. BOARD QUESTIONS Mr. Gitarind asked.whether Essex County had provided any additional proposals or requests durin{ its discussions with the applicant and, if so, how the applicant had responded: Mr. Moronski:stated that he had not been directly involved in the discussions with:the:County.'He explained that Mr. Penke had been involved in those discussions and that his own:knowledge was based on the submitted application, testimony, and discussions with his professional colleagues. Mr. Guarino askéd whether the proposed pedestrian walkways, lighting, sidewalks, and crosswalks had been sufficiently evaluated to create a safe, walkable area for
s with his professional colleagues. Mr. Guarino askéd whether the proposed pedestrian walkways, lighting, sidewalks, and crosswalks had been sufficiently evaluated to create a safe, walkable area for individuals using Crestmont Country Club and its facilities. Mr. Moronski stated that the proposed sidewalk and lighting provided a good foundation for pedestrian access at that location. Mr. Guarino asked whether traffic calming measures, such as speed bumps, were proposed within the country club property. Mr. Moronski stated that he did not know of any specific traffic calming measures proposed on-site. Mayor McCartney stated that she generally agreed with Mr. Moronski's testimony concerning negative community impacts but had additional questions related to the Heyer Gruel report. Mayor McCartney referred to page 6 of 10 of the report and asked for a clearer explanation of the proposed modular block retaining wall, which would reach nearly 21.5 feet in height. She questioned whether the wall could be tiered. Mr. Moronski stated that the 21.5-foot height occurred in a relatively small portion of the more than 1,300 linear feet of retaining walls proposed. He described the condition as unique because of the 23
location and topography. Mr. Moronski explained that the design attempted to strike a balance between providing parking at the existing upper elevation and addressing drainage requirements. Mayor McCartney then referred to the steep slope variance comments on the same page of the review report and asked the Board's planners and engineers whether the testimony had adequately justified the need for the requested steep slope variances. Ms. Apte stated that:she had a follow-up question for Mr. Moronski concerning the steep slope testimony. «Ms. Apte asked whether:every effort had been made in the site plan design to minimize the area of steep slope disturbance. She specifically asked whether alternative designs had been considered-and whether the proposed layout represented the least impactful option with thé fewest necessary steep slope variances. Ms. Apte stated that Mr. Moronski's response would also help address Mayor McCartney's question. Mr. Moronski Stiited that the design was intended to minimize the area of disturbance, particularly the disturbance and removal of existing trees. Mr»Moronski explained that using additional retaining walls or spreading the walls farther’ apart would:create a greater area of disturbance and could require removing more trees. He stated that the'design involved balancing the drainage requirements, parking elevations, and retaining wall configuration. Mr. Moronski stated that tiering the retaining walls would result in greater disturbance. He further explained: that the approximately 21-foot-high portion of the wall extended for ‘only:about 13 linear -feet:out of more than 1,300 linear feet of retaining wall, representing approximately 1% of the total wall length. Mr. Schkolnick‘clarified thatthe retaining wall would have varying heights and that the ‘imaximum height'of approximately 21 feet would occur along only about 13 feet of wall. Ms».McGovern asked what the average retaining wall height would be. Mr. Moronski stated that he did not have the average height available at that moment. Mr. Schkolnick noacknowledged the question and indicated that the information would be looked into. Mr\'Cotexrequested permission to provide additional clarification concerning the retaining wall. Mr. Cote explained'thatithe:stormwater basin tapers downward at onc end and that the approximately 13-foot section where the wall reaches its
e additional clarification concerning the retaining wall. Mr. Cote explained'thatithe:stormwater basin tapers downward at onc end and that the approximately 13-foot section where the wall reaches its maximum height is located at the lowest portion of the basin. . Mr. Cote stated:that the wall is approximately 6 feet high at the opposite end of the basin dind-decreases in height as:iticontinues around the corner. He explained that the highest wall sectioniwas necessary because of the depressed area required to size the stormwater basin. Mr. Cote stated that spreading out the grading or using additional tiers would increase the area of disturbance, extend farther into the existing tree line, and require additional tree removal. Mr. Cote confirmed that alternative alignments and designs had been considered. He stated that the other options would have resulted in greater impacts, additional impervious coverage, and more disturbance to achieve the same result. Chairman Bagoff asked Mr. Moronski whether the retaining wall would be visible to motorists driving along Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Moronski stated that the wall would be set back a considerable distance from the roadway. Mr. Cote also stated that visibility of the wall from Eagle Rock Avenue would be minimal because a tree line would be planted in front of it and the stormwater basin itself would contain landscaping. Chairman Bagoff asked whether evergreen trees could be planted in front of the retaining wall to provide permanent screening and greater density, so motorists would see greenery rather than the wall. Mr. Cote stated that additional trees might be possible but that the 24
applicant would need to ensure they did not reduce the basin's storage volume and that the species could survive in wet conditions. - Mr. Noborine asked for additional information about the construction of the proposed retaining wall. Mr. Cote explained that the proposed modular block wall would have grid reinforcement extending from behind the wall back through the soil. He stated that the grid interrupts the natural soil failure plane and allows the wall to remain standing through mechanical reinforcement. Mr. Cote stated that this type of reinforced wall has been used in numerous developments throughout the area. +\ Mr. Noboririe:asked whether the same type of wall would be used uniformly throughout the site. Mr. Cote:confirmed that the type of wall would be uniform, although the coloration had not yet been determined. =...Ms. Kapferer'asked:whether there was an exhibit illustrating the steep slope impacts. Mr. ueCote displayed the steep slope exhibit EX04, dated February 12, 2026 and confirmed that the overall disturbance was approximately 3.95 acres. He explained that the steep slope disturbance was'concentrated toward the front of the site, primarily along Eagle Rock Awenue. Mr. Cote stated thatthe existing steep slope along Eagle Rock Avenue would be cut back’ to create the 10-foot area adjacent to the curb where the sidewalk would be installed: He explained that a retaining wall would be provided along the frontage for that purpose. Mr. Cote:explainéd that placing the retaining wall close to the proposed parking area: would-avoid the need: fota larger sloped embankment, which would disturb a much greater arearHe stated that the proposed design would disturb only a relatively small portion of the existingssteep slope. Mr. Cote identified another area where the proposed driveway ‘would traverse an existing steep slope. He explained that this condition would be addréssed with»a:tetaining wall on one side of the driveway and that the parking lot ting s'and drive aisle Would ‘eliminate a portion of the existing steep slope. Mr. Cote identified the areas along Eagle Rock» Avenue, the driveway, and the parking lot where steep slope disturbance wouldoccur. He stated that those areas totaled approximately 0.5 acres of : ‘steep slope ‘disturbance. Mr, Cote stated that steep slopes exist throughout the property, but the applicant was not' proposing to
cur. He stated that those areas totaled approximately 0.5 acres of : ‘steep slope ‘disturbance. Mr, Cote stated that steep slopes exist throughout the property, but the applicant was not' proposing to modify the slopes farther east and would disturb only a limited area to the west near Laurel Avenue. > 2. Ms. Kapfererasked'whether most of the steep slope disturbance involved cutting into the existing slopes or whether the work involved a combination of cut and fill. Mr. Cote stated that the work involved a combination of cut and fill. sons. Chairman Bagoff asked whether the applicant had considered making a portion of the bet detention basin a pollinator garden. Mr. Cote stated that one of the basins was designed as a vegetated basin with different planting mixes, shrubs, and trees along the bottom. He explained that the other basin was proposed with a meadow mix. - Chairman Bagoff asked whether the landscape design could incorporate plants specifically intended to create a pollinator garden. Mr. Cote stated that he would ask the landscape architect whether the proposed plantings included flowering trees or other plants suitable for pollinators and whether additional pollinator plantings could be incorporated. BOARD COMMENTS - Council President Scarpa stated that she continued to have several concerns that she did not believe had been adequately addressed, particularly concerning the steep slope variances and the significant number of trees proposed for removal. - Council President Scarpa stated that many of the trees being removed were located on steep slopes and had mature root systems. She expressed concern that replacing mature 25
trees with younger trees, which could take decades to grow, would not immediately replace the functions of the existing root systems. o Mr. Moronski responded that the steep slope disturbance and tree removal were directly related to the requested variances. He reiterated that the applicant was attempting to strike a balance and minimize disturbance to the extent possible. o Mr. Moronski acknowledged that trees would be removed but stated that the replacement trees would fill in the gaps over time. He explained that the tree replacement needed to be weighed against the drainage improvements proposed for both the country club property and Eagle Rock Avenue. sonee-Council President Scarpa stated that she remained concerned about the potential for additional stormwater runoffiand also about the effect of traffic on Pleasantdale Chateau. o.¢Mr: Moronski stated that the drainage and roadway improvements represented public benefitsvand that the application attempted to balance those improvements with minimizing disturbance - » Council President Scarpa stated that she remained concerned. She referred to her own neighborhood;' where mature trees had been removed and young trees planted more than a decade.earlier, while tieighboring properties continued to experience increased flooding. 2)! MroCote responded that the majority of the proposed replacement trees would be approximately 4-inch caliper trees. He explained that although these trees were oe)) cotismaller than the mature trees being removed, a 4-inch caliper tree was more substantial than the approximately 2.5-inch caliper trees commonly used for replacement planting in other municipalities. | paov Mr. Cote stated that using 4-inch caliper trees would provide a larger starting diameter and more substantial replacement planting. ) +. Council Président Scarpa stated that she continued to picture a large, beautiful, mature tree that might have-been growing for 100 years being replaced by a much smaller tree. She questioned how manyvyears it would take for the replacement trees to develop root systerns capable of performing the same function as the mature trees. o. Mr. Cote explained that the Township's tree replacement ordinance uses a \, ‘multiplier based oi the diameter of trees being removed. He stated that replacing one mature tree with multiple new trees would ultimately create a larger combined
ee replacement ordinance uses a \, ‘multiplier based oi the diameter of trees being removed. He stated that replacing one mature tree with multiple new trees would ultimately create a larger combined root structure. o. Mr. Cote described ‘tle Township's tree replacement requirements as a very high standard within the industry and stated that the ordinance was designed to help address the concerns raised by Council President Scarpa. ADDITIONAL TESTIMONY - Mr. Schkolnick asked Mr. Cote to briefly explain the proposed tree replacement numbers in greater detail. - Mr. Cote explained that, in response to the Township Planner's comments, 11 trees proposed within the parking area would not be counted toward the required tree replacement total. He stated that the applicant would add 11 replacement trees to account for that adjustment. - Mr. Cote stated that the original replacement plan included 586 trees, consisting of 303 trees shown in the main project area along the frontage, 239 additional trees elsewhere on the overall property, and 44 trees addressed through off-site planting or a fee in lieu. - Mr. Cote explained that the off-site planting or fee-in-lieu component would increase from 44 to 55 trees to account for the additional 11 replacement trees. 26
- Mr. Cote stated that the revised total would be 597 replacement trees, nearly double the number of trees being removed. He emphasized that the majority of the replacement trees would be approximately 4 inches in diameter. - Mr. Cote stated that the project was not simply removing approximately 300 trees and leaving the land barren. He explained that the replacement plan reflected the substantial requirements of the Township's ordinance and would provide significant new tree planting throughout the property. PROFESSIONAL QUESTIONS +'eMs: Apte asked: Mr. Moronski to clarify the two requested waivers, one involving the removalofitrees-on'slopes of 10% or greater and the other involving the lighting rty Uncillumination-level atthe Eagle Rock Avenue property line. Mr. Moronski explained that i othe lighting issue ‘concernedithe maximum illumination level at the property line and the County'street lighting located within the right-of-way. He stated that the roadway lighting was designed to meet County standards. =tirMsApte referred toithe: proposed lighting fixture mounting height of 27 feet and asked whether:the 3:5+foot-candle illumination level at the property line resulted from the ‘ County-related intersection lighting. Mr. Cote explained that the lighting was intended to properly illuminaté:the! driveway and the intersection. He stated that the applicant was | Juneértaii» whether the illumination requirement would fall under County or Township f jurisdiction and had conservatively requested relief. sMs: Apte asked whether the Al and A2 lighting fixtures shown on the plans were located i \nwjthinrthe: applicant's property. Mr. Cote confirmed that they were and stated that their purpose was to illuminate the driveway. | the ign Ms. Apte:stated that! the applicant should request the lighting waiver because the yndlumination 'standardis' contained in the Township ordinance. She explained that the testimoiy.supporting the waiver would be the need for adequate driveway safety and vlighting at thelintersection: Mr. Cote confirmed that he had included that justification toward the end of his earlier testimony. , =» Msi Apte:asked’Mr. Moronski whether his testimony was that the increased foot-candle Loroi level-was necessary for driveway safety. Mr. Moronski confirmed that it was. PROFESSIONAL COMMENTS - Ms. Apte stated that the application involved
File revisions (1)
- Nov 6, 2026
c1f7e551165725,244,207 bytes