Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026

8 12 26 WO PB Draft Minutes

Preserved file SHA-25689b5155dfd6e8da1e2d6b434b7e2576700ca3fd8942c85eafcf06f348f3f3105

Indexed text

Page 17

that could be seen when exiting the driveway. Mr. Cecini initially referred to the directional arrows, but Mr. Klein clarified that he was asking about sight triangles. ○ Mr. Klein stated that he did not see the sight triangles on the site plan and noted that he was not sure whether the matter had been included as a comment in a prior review letter. ○ The architect, Mr. Jorge Mastropietro, stated that the sight triangles were included in the architectural drawings. The sight triangles were identified on Sheet 13. - Ms. Kapferer asked whether a geotechnical analysis had been performed. Mr. Cecini confirmed that it had. - Ms. Kapferer asked whether the stormwater design provided adequate separation between the stormwater features and the high groundwater table, and whether the percolation rates were adequate. Mr. Cecini confirmed both. - Ms. Kapferer asked about the proposed grocery store and neighboring properties, specifically whether nearby buildings have basements and whether infiltration facilities located near those buildings could create a concern. Mr. Cecini stated that most buildings are designed to have waterproofing up to the grade line as required by code. He noted that water tables fluctuate even without stormwater percolating into the area and stated that he did not have concerns about additional water entering basements. - Ms. Kapferer asked whether Mr. Cecini knew if the neighboring structures had basements. Mr. Cecini stated that he did not know.

Page 18

18 - Ms. Kapferer asked about maintenance of the permeable pavement and how the applicant would ensure that it continues functioning as designed. Mr. Cecini stated that there is a maintenance plan in his report. He indicated that he would need to review the report further to provide the specific maintenance requirements and noted that the requirements depend on the system used and generally follow the manufacturer’s requirements. BOARD COMMENTS - Mr. Guarino explained that the Community House next door currently has approximately 125 children and, as the program increases with the completion of the structure and new classrooms, there could be 300 children or more crossing Main Street during daytime and afternoon hours. He stated that a truck on Main Street would create a significant blindside and that this was one of his main concerns. ○ Ms. Wolfe stated that the applicant had reached out to the Community House to determine whether it had reviewed the plans. She stated that the Community House was familiar with the plans and did not have concerns about the project itself, but its concern was more about the overall circulation of the street and not the impact of this project. - Mr. Guarino stated that he had spoken with the Executive Director of the Community House. He noted that he also sits on the Community House Board and is Chairman of the Pedestrian Safety Advisory Board, which includes two other Planning Board members. - Ms. Wolfe stated that she had spoken with Mr. Paul Cito regarding the plans. Mr. Guarino confirmed that Mr. Cito had also contacted him and that this was the basis for his concerns. - Chairman Bagoff asked Mr. Cecini to confirm for the record that the stormwater management controls would comply with the West Orange Stormwater Management Ordinance. Mr. Cecini confirmed that they would. - Council President Scarpa stated that the project looked beautiful, but that she shared Mr. Guarino’s concern regarding the delivery truck. She stated that she works at Washington School and is intimately familiar with the traffic and dangerous conditions on Main Street, noting that she had personally been involved in an accident there. - Mr. Guarino stated that, because he is a member of the Executive Board of the West Orange Community House and a member of the Boys & Girls Clubs of the United States, and because the organization is a non-profit located

Page 18

that, because he is a member of the Executive Board of the West Orange Community House and a member of the Boys & Girls Clubs of the United States, and because the organization is a non-profit located directly across the street, he felt it was pertinent to recuse himself from any further participation in the application. ○ Ms. McGovern stated that Ms. Kapferer would be voting as an alternate due to the recusal. PROFESSIONAL QUESTIONS - Mr. Greg Valesi asked about the stormwater management system and a comment requesting drainage calculations and drainage area maps. He asked whether those materials had been submitted. Mr. Cecini stated that they should have been submitted but that he was not 100% sure which report Mr. Valesi was reviewing. - Mr. Valesi identified the April 10, 2026 Archeon report and stated that, based on his understanding, the requested materials had not been submitted. Mr. Valesi stated that, although Mr. Cecini had testified that the project complies with the ordinance, he wanted the requested documentation submitted if it had not already been provided.

Page 19

19 ○ Mr. Cecini stated that he had a May 26 report and offered to send it to Mr. Valesi so that the comments could be reviewed and any requirements necessary to comply with the ordinance could be addressed. - Mr. Valesi asked whether Mr. Cecini would agree to comply with the comments contained in the engineering report. Mr. Cecini stated that he would comply as long as the comments were within the ordinance. - Mr. Valesi asked whether the applicant had identified the location of the ADA EV space. Mr. Cecini stated that the current plan did not have an ADA EV space, but that one of the ADA stalls could be converted to an ADA EV space. He noted that some parking would have to be moved because of issues regarding the Fire Department’s preferred location for those spaces. PUBLIC QUESTIONS - Mr. Kevin Malanga, Ridge Road, asked Mr. Cecini about the collection of runoff from the roof. Mr. Cecini stated that the roof runoff would be collected through storm pipes or drains on the roof, which would go to a leader and then connect into the runoff and ultimately the basin. - Mr. Malanga asked where the gutters and leaders would be located on the building. Mr. Cecini stated that their specific locations had not been established for a zoning plan application because that level of detail is typically provided with the construction documents. He stated that the drainage plan does provide a location for the runoff to enter the drainage system. - Mr. Malanga asked whether there would be gutters for the roof along Main Street. Mr. Cecini stated that there would be some form of drainage collection, which could be internal to the roof or could use exterior gutters. - Mr. Malanga asked about a structure that is an extension of the roof attached to the building along the Main Street side. Mr. Cecini stated that the architect would be more appropriate to address that issue because he is handling the site plan. - Mr. Malanga asked whether Mr. Cecini was aware of rain gutters for that structure. Mr. Cecini stated that he was not responsible for the building design and that he is the site plan engineer. He explained that he tells the building designers where the pipe must be placed so that the water enters his storm collection system. - Mr. Malanga asked whether Mr. Cecini had designed a collection system for the structure along Main Street. Mr. Cecini stated that he designed a

Page 19

so that the water enters his storm collection system. - Mr. Malanga asked whether Mr. Cecini had designed a collection system for the structure along Main Street. Mr. Cecini stated that he designed a system that collects the rainwater where it ends, but that the conveyance system is part of the building design, which is typically completed after approvals. - Mr. Malanga asked whether Mr. Mastropietro had discussed rain gutters for the building with Mr. Cecini. Mr. Cecini stated that he believed the matter had been discussed as part of Mr. Mastropietro’s prior testimony and stated that he would leave it to Mr. Mastropietro to address in his testimony. ○ Mr. Malanga stated that he had asked Mr. Mastropietro about the issue and that Mr. Mastropietro had said there would be rain gutters, so he was surprised to hear that the matter had not been discussed with Mr. Cecini. PRESENTATION - The traffic engineer, Mr. Gary Dean, entered on the record; he was sworn under oath. His credentials were accepted by the board and he testified to the following:

Page 20

20 - Mr. Dean stated that the applicant had submitted a Traffic Impact Assessment dated March 11, 2026. - Mr. Dean stated that the Traffic Impact Assessment included background traffic counts at the site and on streets in the immediate vicinity, including Kling Street, Main Street, and Irwin. - Mr. Dean explained that the site is, in essence, a redevelopment. The property is currently developed with a Walgreens that has since closed and a small diner at the northern end of the property. - Mr. Dean stated that the two existing structures would be removed and that the new store would be constructed essentially in their place, but more toward the southern end of the site. - Mr. Dean explained that, instead of having two separate parking lots with two-way driveways as currently exists, the professional team spent significant time evaluating what type of circulation made the most sense for the property given its nature as a grocer. - Mr. Dean stated that the team understood early on that there was sensitivity regarding traffic movement and operations, particularly at Kling Street. - Mr. Dean stated that the team considered two-way driveways as well as one-way driveways with an entrance to the north and an exit to the south. - Mr. Dean explained that, in an effort to minimize the impact on Kling Street, the proposed access has the ingress located opposite Kling Street. ○ This would allow anyone on Kling Street who wanted to come straight across Main Street to do so, while movements would otherwise not be subordinate to or affected by vehicles leaving the site. - Mr. Dean stated that the exit driveway is further to the north, between Kling and Prospect. - Mr. Dean stated that this arrangement was considered the most efficient manner of on- site circulation. It keeps traffic moving in a clockwise orientation and continues to allow access to 90-degree parking spaces. - Mr. Dean stated that, through the process, Mr. Mastropietro had been responsive to concerns regarding cart corrals and other elements typical of a grocery store. - Mr. Dean stated that one of the more significant issues addressed during the various TRC meetings was the desire not to put tractor trailers on Irwin. - Mr. Dean stated that the team looked at a variety of options and determined that, without having the truck penetrate farther to the west and affect the residences, it was prudent to keep

Page 20

s on Irwin. - Mr. Dean stated that the team looked at a variety of options and determined that, without having the truck penetrate farther to the west and affect the residences, it was prudent to keep that activity away from Irwin. - Mr. Dean stated that the applicant did not want to ignore the loading issue but also recognized that bringing the loading activity within the parking lot would result in the loss of too much parking. - Mr. Dean stated that the team therefore considered how Main Street had been re-striped approximately four or five years ago. - Mr. Dean explained that Main Street had previously had two lanes in each direction with no on-street parking, but had been re-striped to one lane in each direction with typical village or CBD-type parallel parking. - Mr. Dean explained that, with the proposed relocation of the various driveways, on-street parking would still be retained, but the parking closest to the building entrance would be restricted as a loading zone so that a truck could safely park along Main Street and merchandise could be offloaded directly into the store. - Mr. Dean presented a Google Street View photograph, identified as Exhibit A3 dated October 2021, as an example of what the applicant did not want to occur.

Page 21

21 - Mr. Dean explained that the photograph showed a typical delivery occurring at the neighboring property, where the truck left insufficient width for traffic to safely pass. He stated that the applicant wanted to capitalize on the parallel parking availability along Main Street to create a temporary loading zone, which he said is frequently done in downtown areas. - Mr. Dean stated that the loading zone would be used for a limited duration, approximately 20 to 25 minutes, to allow a few pallets to be removed from the truck and brought into the store, after which the area would revert to available on-street parking. - Mr. Dean said that the proposed loading arrangement was considered a very practical solution that allowed the applicant to design a sufficient amount of parking for the project. - Mr. Dean explained that if trucks were required to make deliveries on the property, they would have to cross the sidewalk twice, once to enter the site and once to exit. He stated that, out of concern for providing the highest level of safety, the applicant did not want trucks crossing the sidewalk and conflicting with pedestrians. - Mr. Dean stated that, because Main Street is part of the Essex County roadway system, the proposal was reviewed with the County planner, who took no exception to the proposal in terms of safety, traffic, or movements and considered it a creative solution to a typical urban or downtown concern. - Mr. Dean reiterated that keeping trucks off the sidewalk and out of conflict with pedestrians was considered a very practical and safe design that would adequately serve the store, and that the proposal had also been vetted with the applicant. - Mr. Dean stated that he did not intend to get into the details of the traffic study, other than to identify it and discuss the comparison between the current site uses and the proposed use. - Mr. Dean acknowledged that a thriving new grocer on Main Street would likely be a more vibrant business than the current use, or than the uses that could occupy the two existing buildings if they were re-tenanted. - Regarding access and circulation, Mr. Dean explained that the proposed plan provides total on-site traffic flow, with parking essentially all the way around the site, head-in along the perimeter, and rows of parking in the central core to maximize the number of spaces. - Mr. Dean stated that one parking

Page 21

ic flow, with parking essentially all the way around the site, head-in along the perimeter, and rows of parking in the central core to maximize the number of spaces. - Mr. Dean stated that one parking space had been lost due to the cart corral, which he believed was appropriate in response to a concern previously raised by a Board member. - Mr. Dean explained that the plan eliminated the need for individuals to back out of parking spaces and across the sidewalk. - Mr. Dean stated that the parking directly along the north side of the building would be head-in parking and would include two handicap/ADA spaces. The parking would wrap all the way around the parking field, maximizing the number of available spaces. - Mr. Dean stated that there were approximately a dozen interior traditional tandem spaces, all served by 24-foot-wide aisles that allow vehicles to exit from the perpendicular spaces. - Mr. Dean addressed the question of site triangles and stated that the applicant had endeavored to provide low-level landscaping at the exit, below 36 inches in driver height. He said that, if necessary, the landscaping plan could be amended to clarify that requirement. - Mr. Dean explained that there are no buildings or other obstructions affecting the site triangles. He noted that parallel parking spaces are the one feature that theoretically affects site triangles because vehicles parked on the street can be within the sight triangle,

Page 22

22 although people are expected to be able to look through the glass of a parked vehicle to safely enter and exit a driveway. - Mr. Dean stated that this condition is common along Main Street, both at driveways and various intersections, because parallel parking can theoretically place an object within a site triangle. - Mr. Dean discussed the proposed bump-out at Irwin Place, explaining that it would clean up the area, improve sight triangles, provide additional curbing, improve visibility of the turning path, and allow a clearer line of sight for vehicles exiting Irwin Place. - Mr. Dean stated that the proposed treatment at Irwin Place would allow for additional landscaping or streetscape treatment, or potentially a combination of both. - Mr. Dean stated that the applicant was retaining, and potentially augmenting, landscaping and street trees along Main Street. - Mr. Dean explained that the store entrance would be located at the northeast corner of the building, providing a convenient means of access for pedestrians. He stated that residents in the immediate neighborhood could have access to a grocer directly along Main Street instead of getting into a car and driving elsewhere. - Mr. Dean said that the applicant hoped the location would attract some pedestrian traffic and that every effort had been made to ensure pedestrians and drivers have clear lines of sight. - Mr. Dean clarified that the truck depicted on the plan was not a lowboy but a standard refrigerated tractor-trailer with either a 48-foot or 53-foot trailer. - Mr. Dean explained that the tractor-trailer would position itself within the parallel parking spaces near the building entrance, allowing inventory to be brought directly into the store. The truck would pull across the entrance driveway, pull straight in, and then move forward to exit. - Mr. Dean stated that if the truck and its circulation were accommodated on-site, the applicant would lose at least four parking spaces and probably more. He explained that during the design process, truck templates had been placed on the plan and evaluated. - Mr. Dean stated that, considering the limited duration of deliveries, bringing the truck on- site would be a detriment to the efficiency and functionality of the overall site. He said the proposed loading arrangement was considered the more prudent and practical design solution. - Mr. Dean

File revisions (1)