Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Nov 4, 2026

9 2 26 WO PB Draft Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256e517e0133e501772133e3ec02fd3a94ed8399b86900e5b5caa6858d51f060903

Indexed text

Page 12

d. ○ 10-year storm: 23.47 CFS existing and 19.76 CFS proposed. ○ 100-year storm: 44.56 CFS existing and 38.87 CFS proposed. - Mr. Cote provided the following rates for Point of Analysis 1 under future storm conditions: ○ 2-year storm: 16.83 CFS existing and 14.07 CFS proposed. ○ 10-year storm: 29.21 CFS existing and 24.77 CFS proposed. ○ 100-year storm: 58.39 CFS existing and 53.61 CFS proposed. - Mr. Cote provided the following existing and proposed peak flow rates for Point of Analysis 2, located at the other end of the site, under current storm conditions: ○ 2-year storm: 9.63 CFS existing and 5.67 CFS proposed. ○ 10-year storm: 17.05 CFS existing and 10.31 CFS proposed. ○ 100-year storm: 37.74 CFS existing and 23.96 CFS proposed. - Mr. Cote provided the following rates for Point of Analysis 2 under future storm conditions: ○ 2-year storm: 11.97 CFS existing and 7.27 CFS proposed. ○ 10-year storm: approximately 21.2 CFS existing and 14.02 CFS proposed. ○ 100-year storm: 42.47 CFS existing and 31.63 CFS proposed. - Ms. Bennett asked where stormwater from the modified site would discharge. Mr. Cote explained that the proposed stormwater connections would be located within Eagle Rock Avenue, with pipes running east and west of Oval Road and connecting to the existing County stormwater drainage system near the limits of the project.

Page 13

13 - Ms. Bennett asked whether additional runoff volume, velocity, or concentration would ultimately reach neighboring residential properties. Mr. Cote explained that current stormwater design standards focus on controlling the rate of discharge rather than the total volume. He acknowledged that the additional impervious surface would increase runoff volume but stated that the proposed detention systems would reduce discharge rates in accordance with NJDEP and Township requirements. - Ms. Bennett asked whether the stormwater analysis accounted for current rainfall conditions and increasingly intense future storm events or relied solely on historical design assumptions. Mr. Cote confirmed that the analysis included both current and future storm events, as reflected in the runoff calculations he had previously provided. - Ms. Bennett asked where stormwater would go if the proposed detention system exceeded its design capacity. Mr. Cote explained that both basins would have outfall spillways directing excess water onto Eagle Rock Avenue. He stated that, during storms exceeding the system's capacity, the water would flow to the same locations where runoff currently flows, without changing the existing discharge points. - Ms. Bennett asked whether the need for the proposed improvements, or the conditions creating that need, had been anticipated when Crestmont Country Club received its 2023 and 2024 approvals. Mr. Cote stated that he could not address that question because he had not been involved in those applications. - Ms. Bennett asked whether Mr. Cote had reviewed the previous applications. Mr. Cote stated that he was familiar with the improvements involving pickleball facilities and a building near the parking lot, but those applications had been prepared by a different engineer. - Ms. Bennett asked whether any of the improvements currently before the Planning Board had been discussed, contemplated, or required as part of the 2023 Planning Board approval or the 2024 Zoning Board approval. Mr. Cote stated that he did not know and was not aware of whether those improvements had been considered during the earlier applications. - Ms. Bennett asked whether any conditions had changed since those approvals that would make the current improvements necessary. Mr. Cote stated that this was more of an operational question than an engineering question and that he could

Page 13

tions had changed since those approvals that would make the current improvements necessary. Mr. Cote stated that this was more of an operational question than an engineering question and that he could not answer it. - Ms. Bennett asked whether the current application was intended to correct an unforeseen consequence of previously approved development or uses. Mr. Cote stated that he was not aware of any such consequence. - Mr. Lawrence Cohen of 20 Lincoln Avenue asked Mr. Cote for his professional opinion regarding the existing country club driveway, which had been used for many years. He questioned whether the original driveway location had been a reasonable decision, given the visibility to the left and right and its long history of use. Mr. Cote stated that he could not comment on the reasoning behind the original driveway design because he was not familiar with its history. However, he stated that the existing driveway's alignment was not appropriate for vehicles exiting the property - Mr. Cohen asked whether the original driveway might have been selected because of its sightlines, seclusion, and privacy for the country club. Mr. Cote reiterated that he did not know the reasons behind the original design. - Mr. Cohen also questioned the steepness of the existing driveway, and Mr. Cote stated that the grade varied along its length. - Mr. Seth Weisleder of 17 Howell Drive, asked Mr. Cote to explain the existing stormwater runoff problem along Eagle Rock Avenue and how the proposed application would address it. Mr. Cote explained that stormwater currently runs from the property onto Eagle Rock Avenue without being controlled by a detention system. He stated that

Page 14

14 the proposed improvements would capture the runoff and slow its discharge. He also explained that the existing drainage pipes along Eagle Rock Avenue were designed before current stormwater regulations and that the project would provide an opportunity to upgrade those pipes to meet today's standards. - Mr. Weisleder questioned whether the proposed drainage improvements would affect only a small portion of Eagle Rock Avenue rather than improving the entire roadway. Mr. Cote confirmed that the improvements would be limited to the portion of Eagle Rock Avenue within the project's work area. - Mr. Weisleder asked what specific existing problem justified the drainage improvements and whether there was data or a study showing the need for the work. Mr. Cote explained that the existing drainage system is substandard under current stormwater regulations because its conveyance structures were not designed to accommodate the increased flow rates now required for current storm events. - Mr. Weisleder asked how much of Eagle Rock Avenue would be improved. Mr. Cote stated that the improvements would extend from Laurel Avenue at the western end to the eastern end of the Crestmont Country Club property, within the limits of the applicant's work. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether the retaining walls, grading, and stormwater improvements would still be necessary if Crestmont Country Club were not adding the additional parking spaces. Mr. Cote explained that the retaining walls were associated with maintaining appropriate grades for the parking lot, while the stormwater detention systems would also be required because of the proposed widening of Eagle Rock Avenue and the additional turning lanes. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether the stormwater improvements for the parking lot and the roadway could be completed separately. Mr. Cote explained that the stormwater management required for the roadway improvements had been combined with the stormwater management for the parking lot into one system. He acknowledged that different components could be designed independently but stated that the current application addressed the improvements together. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether the widening and regrading of Eagle Rock Avenue were primarily being undertaken because of the new exit and traffic signal or whether the improvements would have been required regardless. Mr. Cote stated that the

Page 14

and regrading of Eagle Rock Avenue were primarily being undertaken because of the new exit and traffic signal or whether the improvements would have been required regardless. Mr. Cote stated that the work had been requested in connection with the installation of the traffic signal associated with the settlement agreement. He also stated that, based on discussions involving the applicant's traffic engineer, he understood that the County supported the project. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether the applicant had considered alternative parking lot layouts that could provide additional spaces without requiring as much grading, retaining wall construction, tree removal, or work along Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote stated that the applicant had considered the design and developed the proposed layout to minimize impacts. - Mr. Weisleder asked why the applicant could not relocate or redesign the driveway and parking lot differently to address visibility and alignment concerns without the other proposed site changes. Mr. Cote reiterated that alternative designs could result in greater impervious surface, additional tree removal, and increased disturbance to steep slopes. He stated that the proposed design was the most suitable option developed to minimize those impacts. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether Crestmont Country Club would become responsible for assisting the County with stormwater management because of the additional runoff associated with the project. Mr. Cote stated that the County would benefit from the

Page 15

15 proposed improvements because the applicant would be upgrading existing substandard drainage pipes and roadway drainage structures. - Mr. Weisleder asked whether the project would affect West Orange's stormwater containment or control. Mr. Cote explained that the proposed stormwater design complies with applicable requirements for reducing post-development discharge rates and would improve downstream receiving conditions. - Mr. Justin Goldsman of Moran Road asked Mr. Cote about the capacity of a standard bioretention basin to absorb or prevent stormwater runoff. Mr. Cote explained that the bioretention component of the basin is primarily intended for water quality rather than water quantity. - Mr. Goldsman asked whether the bioretention basin also plays a role in reducing runoff and requested an estimate of its capacity. Mr. Cote explained that each basin is designed differently and that the proposed system was designed to meet stormwater discharge requirements. He referenced reducing the 2-year storm discharge rate to 50%, the 10-year storm discharge rate to 75%, and the 100-year storm discharge rate to 80% of the applicable existing rates. - Mr. Goldsman asked whether Mr. Cote could estimate how many trees would provide the equivalent stormwater management capacity of the proposed bioretention basins. Mr. Cote stated that he had no way to make that comparison and reiterated that the project had been designed to meet the required discharge reductions for both current storm conditions and projected future storm conditions for the year 2100. - Mr. Goldsman asked whether questions concerning wildlife should be directed to a subsequent witness. Mr. Cote stated that he was not certain how those questions would be addressed during the application. - Mr. Panullo referred to Ms. Bennett's earlier questions concerning the stormwater system and asked Mr. Cote to clarify his statement that certain stormwater conditions would remain the same as they are today. Mr. Cote explained that his earlier statement concerned what would happen if a storm exceeded the capacity of the proposed detention basins. He stated that excess stormwater would flow into the same drainage systems and locations along Eagle Rock Avenue that currently receive runoff. He emphasized that the project would not redirect stormwater to different watersheds or other areas of the Township. - Mr.

Page 15

systems and locations along Eagle Rock Avenue that currently receive runoff. He emphasized that the project would not redirect stormwater to different watersheds or other areas of the Township. - Mr. Panullo asked whether Mr. Cote could address the widths of the proposed driveway, roadway, and sidewalks as part of his civil engineering testimony. Mr. Cote stated that the proposed country club driveway would be 24 feet wide and would function as an exit- only driveway, with two 12-foot lanes leading to the proposed traffic signal at Eagle Rock Avenue. He explained that the roadway lane widths had been addressed by the traffic engineer and would comply with County requirements. - Mr. Panullo asked where the widening of Eagle Rock Avenue would occur. Mr. Cote explained that the widening would take place entirely along the Crestmont Country Club side of Eagle Rock Avenue, using the frontage of the country club property to accommodate the additional roadway width. - Mr. Panullo asked whether the widening was intended to provide one additional lane. Mr. Cote explained that the widening would accommodate a center left-turn lane serving Oval Road at the proposed signalized intersection. - Mr. Panullo asked Mr. Cote to confirm that the land necessary to widen Eagle Rock Avenue along the Crestmont Country Club frontage would come from the country club property. Mr. Cote confirmed that this was correct. - Mr. Panullo asked Mr. Cote how wide the proposed additional lane on Eagle Rock Avenue would be. Mr. Cote stated that the lane would be approximately 11 feet wide

Page 16

16 - Mr. Panullo asked whether the sidewalk requested by Chairman Bagoff at the previous meeting would be constructed within the additional 11-foot roadway widening. Mr. Cote clarified that the 11 feet represented the asphalt widening. He explained that beyond the curb line, the County requires a cleared, relatively flat area, and the sidewalk requested by the Board could be accommodated within that area. The sidewalk would run along Eagle Rock Avenue from Laurel Avenue to the eastern end of the project or property limits. - Mr. Panullo asked whether the sidewalk had already been accommodated in the plans submitted before the Board requested it. Mr. Cote stated that the sidewalk was requested after the design had been submitted and would be made a condition of the resolution. He explained that although the Township requested the sidewalk, the County would have jurisdiction over its final design. - Mr. Panullo questioned whether the plans currently on file provided sufficient width for the sidewalk and related improvements. Mr. Cote explained that the proposed plans already accommodated the necessary width and grading. He stated that the area adjacent to the curb would already be leveled off and that the sidewalk could be installed without additional roadway widening or changes to the proposed grading. - Mr. Panullo referred to Mr. Tractenberg's earlier questions concerning the proposed retaining wall, which substantially exceeds the height permitted by ordinance. He asked whether adding the sidewalk along the widened roadway and into the hillside would increase the height of the retaining wall. Mr. Cote stated that the retaining wall would not be affected by the addition of the sidewalk. - Mr. Panullo asked about previous testimony indicating that a portion of the Crestmont Country Club property along Eagle Rock Avenue would be conveyed to the County. Mr. Cote confirmed that the proposed conveyance was shown on the plans. - Mr. Panullo asked how much property would be conveyed. Mr. Cote stated that approximately 9,446 square feet of land along the Eagle Rock Avenue frontage would be conveyed to the County. He explained that the strip of land would extend along the frontage and vary in width depending on the roadway geometry. - Mr. Panullo asked whether the land conveyed to the County would also accommodate utilities and infrastructure associated with the

Page 16

ng the frontage and vary in width depending on the roadway geometry. - Mr. Panullo asked whether the land conveyed to the County would also accommodate utilities and infrastructure associated with the proposed traffic signal, including electrical power. Mr. Cote confirmed that the easements and improvements associated with the signalized intersection would be part of the overall process. - Mr. Panullo asked whether blasting would be required for the proposed improvements. Mr. Cote stated that he was not aware at that time whether blasting would be necessary. - Mr. Panullo asked whether a geotechnical study had been completed. Mr. Cote explained that a soils investigation had been performed for stormwater management purposes. - Ms. Lori Hassell of 61 Lapis Circle, asked whether alternatives had been considered for relocating the Crestmont Country Club driveway farther along Eagle Rock Avenue toward the end of the property or farther along Laurel Avenue. She asked whether there were any negative or opposing reasons for not pursuing those alternatives instead of the proposed traffic signal and driveway alignment. Mr. Cote explained that the alternative driveway locations had previously been addressed in the traffic testimony provided by Mr. Penke. ○ Ms. Hassell clarified that she was asking from a civil engineering standpoint rather than a traffic standpoint. - Mr. Cote stated that the positioning of the proposed intersection was largely driven by traffic considerations and that the existing one-way entrance and exit configuration was related to the club's operations. He explained that his civil engineering review focused on grading, drainage,

Page 17

17 and other site design elements rather than the operational or traffic-related decisions. - Ms. Hassell asked whether there were any civil engineering reasons to reject alternative driveway locations. Mr. Cote stated that, from his civil engineering perspective, there was no benefit to the alternatives in terms of drainage, impacts to existing trees, or other site conditions. - Ms. Hassell asked whether Mr. Cote had been directed to design the driveway at the proposed location rather than analyze other possible locations. Mr. Cote explained that he had analyzed the corridor in relation to the existing driveway, the proposed on-site improvements, stormwater management, and the connection to the proposed signalized intersection. - Ms. Rachel Klein of Howell Drive, asked whether the applicant was seeking variances under the Township's steep slope ordinance because the proposed roadway widening and improvements would extend farther into the steep slopes on the Crestmont Country Club property. Mr. Cote confirmed that the applicant was seeking steep slope variances for the project. - Ms. Klein asked whether Mr. Cote had seen other retaining walls constructed in the Township. Mr. Schkolnick objected to the question. Mr. Cote stated that he could not offer an opinion on retaining walls designed by other engineers or projects in which he had not participated. - Mr. Tractenberg asked to clarify Mr. Cote's earlier responses to Mr. Misarti regarding the comments and recommended changes contained in the Planning Board professionals' review letters. Mr. Tractenberg asked whether the applicant intended to address the professionals' comments only as conditions of approval, after the Planning Board acted on the application, rather than submitting revised site plans for the Board to consider before making its decision. Mr. Cote stated that the applicant had agreed to address the comments through resolution compliance if approval were granted. - Mr. Tractenberg asked whether those revisions would be addressed only if and after the Board approved the application. Mr. Cote confirmed that this was correct. - Mr. Tractenberg asked whether the other comments and requests from the Planning Board professionals would therefore not be addressed before the Board made its decision. Mr. Cote explained that a majority of the items had already been addressed through testimony and that the

File revisions (1)