Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Dec 2, 2026

Crestmont_West_Orange_2026 06 03_CONDENSED_4up_with_Keyword_Index

Preserved file SHA-2560c791e65cb51f4c3f0a1c4b988c8817340beaea25e3e2fc6a25daec644b4e373

Indexed text

Page 10

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy / Pehnke - Direct 31 MS. McGOVERN: Mr. Pehnke, please raise your right hand. K A R L P E H N K E, APPLICANT’S WITNESS, SWORN MS. McGOVERN: Thank you. MR. SCHKOLNICK: Okay. Chairman, I know Mr. Pehnke has been recognized but I am going -- in this proceeding, obviously want to have a -- quite a complete record here, so I’m going to ask him to place his credentials into the record. THE WITNESS: Certainly. So for the record, again, my name is Karl Pehnke, associate principal with Langan Engineering and Environmental Services. My offices are located at 100 University Square Boulevard in Princeton, New Jersey. I am a registered professional engineer in the state of New Jersey. My license is in good standing. I’ve been prac -- my area of expertise is traffic engineering, which I’ve been practicing for some 40-something years now. I have appeared before West Orange in the past and qualified as such. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Do any of the -- MR. SCHKOLNICK: Chairman, I’d sub -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: I’m sorry. Go right ahead, Mr. Schkolnick. MR. SCHKOLNICK: I’m sorry. I’d submit Mr.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 32 Pehnke as an expert in the field of traffic engineering. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Do any members of the board have any questions about Mr. Pehnke’s ex - - expertise? Seeing none, we accept Mr. Pehnke as an expert in traffic engineering. Go right ahead, Sir. MR. SCHKOLNICK: Thank you. DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. SCHKOLNICK: Q Karl, you’ve obviously analyzed this project in terms of its traffic and traffic safety features. Is that accurate? A That is correct. Q And can you provide the board with an overview of the -- of the civil- and traffic-related issues and the challenges and -- and the benefits to Crestmont and the community? A I can. And let me pull up my screen-sharing. I’m going to make sure -- let’s see. Q And Karl, you’re going to be using only documents that were in our application documents and that are available online, nothing new? A That’s correct. Q And I’m going to ask, when you refer to a document, you call out the sheet and the last revision date just to make sure we all have it tied together.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 33 We have not submitted revised plans at this

Page 10

d the last revision date just to make sure we all have it tied together.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 33 We have not submitted revised plans at this time, Chairman, so there’s only one set. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. BY MR. SCHKOLNICK: Q Okay? This was marked as A-1. This is the aerial. You’re going to use that, Karl? A Correct. Q Okay. A-1, this was marked earlier tonight. A That’s correct. So by way of a little bit of -- of background and as inferred by Ms. Cancellaro just a few minutes ago, planning for this project has certainly spanned a long time. I became involved about two and a half years ago and was retained by West Essex Highland, LLC to progress the design of improvements along Eagle Rock Avenue as well as the traffic signal installation at Oval Road. Prior to that, my -- the predecessor traffic engineer who has since retired, Mr. Walter Lublanecki, had been substantially involved with the West Essex Highland project, the county, the municipality, as -- on prior applications and through the development of the settlement agreement and, ultimately, development of the concept of improvements along Eagle Rock Avenue and Oval Road, which I’ve taken over and have been progressing the design of.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 34 That design effort has also incorporated, because of impacts on -- associated with widenings, the coordination with the Crescent -- Crestmont Country Club, which my partner, John Cote, who’ll be re- testifying a little further, coordinated on the site design features that married to the roadway improvement. So there’s been a design coordination effort between the -- what I would call the public improvement that is being designed under -- under my signature versus the integration and the related site improvements that occur as a result of the -- the widenings and improvements at -- at Oval Road. So one of the -- the initial efforts in -- in the design process and it certainly, as I said, has spanned many years, but I’ve familiarized myself as it -- as I got involved with this project is understanding basically the existing conditions and warranting conditions for an improvement and the need, the analysis of those factors related to the existing operations and the safety of the -- the study area ultimately with a goal to develop a --

Page 10

d warranting conditions for an improvement and the need, the analysis of those factors related to the existing operations and the safety of the -- the study area ultimately with a goal to develop a -- an improvement that improves the overall safety and operation of the - - the project area and really represents the best solution for improving overall safety and operations, and -- and that’s really what we do from an engineering

Page 11

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 35 standpoint and a -- with regard to a traffic signal, a warranting standpoint. There is guidance, you know, in design. That guidance includes design manuals by the New Jersey Department of Transportation, design standards in this case that are provided by Essex County; they have certain things they like designed in certain ways, so they have design standards that we follow. And then with regard to traffic signal design, we have standards as defined in the Manual of Uniform Traffic Control Devices, which is quite regularly updated, one of which is guidance on consideration of a traffic signal and -- and when -- when to consider it when it’s maybe warranted. There is guidance in the MUTCD in terms of warranting factors, which are volume- related, pedestrian-related, crash-related; all sorts of warrants. General traffic engineers focus more on the -- the volume-related warrants and then engineering judgment as guided by the MUTCD with regard to factors that exist that might suggest that signalization and improvements at an intersection make sense. So, with regard to this particular area, you know, I know the board is well familiar with it, but there’s a few things that are occurring, and it starts at -- at Oval Road. Obviously, we know Oval Road is -- is a1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 36 roadway that serves into the West Essex Highlands. It currently comes down to Eagle Rock Road, and I’m referring to the -- the exhi -- the Oval aerial exhibit. It connects to Eagle Rock Avenue. Eagle Rock Avenue at this location is a four-lane road. It provides two travel lanes per direction. In the -- what I would call the westbound direction, you have a through lane and then you have a lane that can be traveled by through vehicles and then -- and right- turn vehicles onto Oval Road. In the eastbound direction, there are again two lanes. The southern lane or the curb lane carries through traffic and then the middle lane, the center lane, carries traffic that both would travel through the intersection or would slow and stop and wait for gaps to make a left onto Oval Road. And then Oval Road has a -- has its approach. At the intersection, it’s -- it -- it is stop- sign-controlled and basically, motorists approaching and wanting to turn onto

Page 11

o make a left onto Oval Road. And then Oval Road has a -- has its approach. At the intersection, it’s -- it -- it is stop- sign-controlled and basically, motorists approaching and wanting to turn onto Eagle Rock Avenue have to come to a stop, look left, right, and choose gaps in the traffic flow on Eagle Rock Avenue which, as everybody is aware, is relatively high; in the area of 800 vehicles per hour to over 1200 vehicles per hour, depending upon the time of day. So it is a -- an1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 37 important pie -- roadway in -- in the -- in the Essex County infrastructure and it is also well-traveled. There are some challenges at Oval Road and Eagle Rock Avenue that consider -- that weigh into consideration. As I said, heading in the eastbound direction, left turns are made from a through travel lane. That can be problematic with vehicles stopped and vehicles progressing behind them and having to -- to move around them. So that’s a condition that is existing that is of concern, that -- that certainly has been considered in the design of improvements to this intersection. On the Oval Road approach, there are also some -- some challenges. Looking right when you arrive at the intersection, there are very much restricted sight distances. Those sight distance restrictions occur from the fence line that’s occurring along the face of Essex Fells Country Club; that creates some sight distance, sight line challenges, particularly as Eagle Rock Road bends away, so seeing oncoming traffic can be challenging. As the -- the summer season progresses, that becomes more challenging as vegetation grows in and overgrows and -- and isn’t maintained. Winter months, a little easier. Summer months and fall months, that -1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 38 - that sight line becomes challenging. That sight line is also a little bit restricted looking in the other direction, a little less so since there is a curve and the advantage to look up the curve to the left, but there is also a fence and vegetative overgrowth that creates some challenges looking left. The right -- the right is the more restrictive sight line. So the intersection has conditions today that warrant the need for improvements and changes in -- in traffic controls. The volumes that exist today on

Page 11

-- the right is the more restrictive sight line. So the intersection has conditions today that warrant the need for improvements and changes in -- in traffic controls. The volumes that exist today on Oval Road and Eagle Rock Avenue also do meet the -- the tenets of what’s known as warrant 2, which is a four- hour warrant. And then -- so not considering any further development along Oval Road, the -- the West Essex Highland project, for instance, a signal at this location, based upon the conditions I described, and guidance in the MUTCD, it’s -- it is warranted to -- to signalize or change the control of the -- the intersection to a signal. So that has been known, I think, quite frankly, for quite some time and has been discussed and, you know, for the most part, is probably more of a funding issue in terms of the county or anyone being able to advance it, which is one of the reasons why it’s

Page 12

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 39 probably been addressed in the settlement agreement to bring the resources to bear and -- and making that happen. So, the other thing to discuss is Wesmont (sic) Country Club. So as we identified the improvements through the years to be done at Eagle Rock Avenue, one of the major parts of those improvements was the widening of Eagle Rock Avenue to provide a left turn lane on Oval Road. To install the left turn lane, basically, we need more pavement. And the, you know, valuations that were undertaken really indicated that that pavement wanted to push to the south, towards Crestmont Country Club, and that would allow the provision for the additional pavement that could create the lengthening of the left turn lane at Laurel Avenue, improving that traffic flow as well as the creation of the separated left turn lane onto Oval Road. So that really started to involve the Crestmont Country Club. In addition, installation of traffic signal equipment requires a footprint. Installation of underground and over -- overhead utilities, that also push into the country club. So as those discussions started underway, it also became clear from the country club’s perspective that they had -- have some challenges.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 40 And as everybody’s aware, the existing and Mr. Cote described the existing circulation on the site, or Dana described, is -- is really the -- the one-way circulation that comes in from Laurel Avenue feeds into their drop-off porte cocheres activities and then out into their existing parking fields and then the egress accommodated by a travel route through the lower parking field and down the egress drive that exists today that really intersects Eagle Rock Avenue at a fairly acute angle, which is not such a great thing. It creates some challenges, again, in -- in sight lines, looking over your shoulder to look left. And also, similar to Oval Road, there are sight line challenges looking right, particularly around this bend that are influenced by the -- the overgrowth and border area plantings that restrict the ability to see, particularly, again, as the summer season and fall season continues around that bend. So there are challenges there. There’s the grading. There’s circulation through -- through

Page 12

ict the ability to see, particularly, again, as the summer season and fall season continues around that bend. So there are challenges there. There’s the grading. There’s circulation through -- through the middle of the parking field, all of which really, you know, are not great things for the country club, so they really took the opportunity in working with my partner and West Essex Highlands, LLC to marry their needs, which also included prior planning that they had1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 41 been in -- in progress on to improve their parking and take advantage of the traffic signal. So what resulted is -- resulted in that is this application and this application involves, as I said, a public improvement, and we’ll go into a little more detail on that, as well as the site improvements. And the site improvements are -- are fairly straightforward. Mr. Cote will get into them further, but basically, we are adding the 36 parking spaces. Those spaces are being added in accordance with more proper standards, good -- good circulation elements, good parking. And the exit -- the exit road is really being disconnected and moved away from circulating through -- through the parking lot. So the on-site circulation and parking of the Crestmont Country Club is -- is being improved and then the egress drive is being brought down at a proper grade and at a proper angle, more importantly, 90 degrees, into Eagle Rock Avenue. And it’s being moved to take advantage of the traffic signal. So that does a few things. It gives them the benefit of the impact on their site with taking by having the internal circulation improved, the egress improved from a safety and operations standpoint, and controlled by the -- the traffic signal. And then the1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 42 public benefit that results from that is the elimination of a point of conflict that exists separate from -- from other roads. We -- we have the -- the driveway now aligned, making a singular point of conflict, and having a combined traffic signal control at that -- at that location. So that’s the -- the general overview. I am going to go to a piece of the design plans that talk about a little more detail. These are also in the record. They are the preliminary -- Q Karl, just one thing, one or two

Page 12

the general overview. I am going to go to a piece of the design plans that talk about a little more detail. These are also in the record. They are the preliminary -- Q Karl, just one thing, one or two little things, before we go onto something more specific. You mentioned MUTDC (sic) -- A M-U -- Manual of Uniform Traffic Control Devices, MUTCD. Q Okay. Can you just say that one more time so we can get that on the record? A The Manual of Uniform Traffic Control Devices, otherwise known as the MUTCD. Q MUTCD. Okay. And I just want you to talk about the slope of the existing egress when it comes in. Dana mentioned that. That’s a challenge. Do you know the percentages offhand? A I don’t. I know the new percentages, which we’ve designed to county standards. The county has a design

Page 13

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 43 standard to bring it in relatively flat before we climb up to an eight percent slope. The existing driveway basically -- oh. I should introduce this. So this is the -- a sheet out of -- it’s actually sheet 14 of 22 out of the preliminary roadway -- Eagle Rock Avenue roadway improvement plans I prepared under my signature dated February 12th of 2026. So basically, the existing driveway runs down and connects with Eagle Rock Avenue basically between the Pleasantdale Chateau driveway and wake -- Wakeman Street. It’s a continuous grade down and then meets just on the inside of the -- the radius and just to the west of land that was previously donated, I believe, to West Orange Township. So that grade doesn’t really meet the county standards. The proposed grade that we would have on the new roadway has been designed to meet the county standards and then come up into the site, so part of the impacts on the site that Mr. Cote will discuss is how they -- how they integrated the need to bring the road up at a proper grade and then deal with the -- the parking lots and -- and meet the parking lots. That was -- that was a challenge that he worked closely with the country club on and I was on the periphery on that. So he could probably talk to you more about that.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Pehnke - Direct 44 So going to sheet 14 of -- of 22, basically this is the -- the signing and striping plan from the project and it really looks -- it’s really focused on the Oval Road and Eagle Rock Avenue new drive -- and the new driveway from Crestmont Country Club. So as I indicated, we are widening Eagle Rock Avenue. So that widening all occurs on the south side of Eagle Rock Avenue. There is no change in the curb line adjacent to the Essex Fells Country Club. There are no changes to the curb lines on Oval Road. All of the widening occurs to the south, to -- to this applicant, the Crestmont Country Club. So we basically add roughly 12 -- 12 feet -- 12 to 13 feet of pavement. And then behind the pavement, we also now grade the border with what’s called a border area, which is the area eight to ten feet behind the curb, we grade that flat. So it’s a walkable surface through there. That’s generally done to make sure that you have proper sight lines for people

File revisions (1)