Minutes · Sep 2, 2026
September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes
c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7Indexed text
testimony was that the increased foot-candle Loroi level-was necessary for driveway safety. Mr. Moronski confirmed that it was. PROFESSIONAL COMMENTS - Ms. Apte stated that the application involved approximately four larger C variances, including the steep slope-related variances, and explained that the Board needed to consider the distinction between C1 hardship variances and C2 variances. - Ms. Apte stated that Mr. Moronski had grouped the steep slope variances together as C1 hardship variances because they were related to the property's topographic conditions. o Ms. Apte explained that the requested steep slope relief included disturbance within steep slope areas and reductions in the required setbacks. She stated that for slopes between 10% and 30%, the ordinance requires a 50-foot setback, while the applicant proposed 10 feet. - Ms. Apte further stated that for slopes greater than 30%, the ordinance requires a 100- foot setback, while the applicant again proposed 10 feet. 27
Ms. Apte explained that these variances were being considered together because they arose from the topography of the property. She referred to Mr. Cote's colorized steep slope analysis exhibit as providing a visual representation of the existing site conditions. Ms. Apte referred to her earlier question about whether the applicant had selected the best design to reduce disturbance and minimize the variances required because of the topography. Ms. Apte explained that, under the Municipal Land Use Law, the Board must consider the positive criteria for a Cl hardship variance, including whether the property has an exceptional condition such as narrowness, unusual topography, or another physical feature creating the hardship. » Ms; Apte explained that the Board must also consider the negative criteria, including whether the variances could be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without stbstantially impairing the intent and purpose of the zone plan and zoning ordinance. Ms) A\ipte:emphasized the word "substantial" and stated that the Board needed to evaluate ‘whether the applicant!had demonstrated that the proposed site design minimized the ss Necessary variances’ andsassociated impacts while addressing the topographic hardship. Ms: Apte stated that the applicant was seeking the steep slope relief based on those site conditions and the design alternatives considered. Ms. Apte next addressed the parking variance. She stated that the ordinance requires almost/700 parking spacés for the existing use, while the property currently has 256 spaces and the applicant proposes increasing the total to 292 spaces. 1oMs. Apte explained that the additional parking would improve the existing ‘nonconforming condition ‘but would not eliminate the parking variance because the total would remain substantially below the ordinance requirement. Ms: Apte stated'that another requested variance concerned the distance between the >, parking area and the fence: She explained that, according to Mr. Moronski's testimony, this ‘condition was related to the proposed layout and the physical conditions of the property. »uMs:.' Apte also identified:the retaining wall height variance and stated that Mr. Moronski had testified that the wall height was driven by the property's topography and therefore supported by the C1 hardship criteria. Ms. Apte explained that
ll height variance and stated that Mr. Moronski had testified that the wall height was driven by the property's topography and therefore supported by the C1 hardship criteria. Ms. Apte explained that much of the applicant's testimony concerned the hardships created by the property's physical conditions and the need for variances to accommodate the proposed improvements. Ms. Apte stated that the’ parking space variance and the variance involving the distance between the parking area and the fence were being requested under the C2 criteria. Ms. Apte explained that, for a C2 variance, the Board must consider whether the benefits of granting the variance outweigh the detriments. Ms. Apte stated that the applicant had testified that it did not need approximately 700 parking spaces for its operations but did need additional spaces. She explained that the proposed increase would reduce the extent of the existing parking variance without fully meeting the ordinance requirement. Ms. Apte stated that, regarding the distance between the parking area and the fence, the applicant had testified that there would be no negative impact on neighboring properties and that the benefits of the proposed layout would outweigh any detriment resulting from the reduced setback. Ms. Apte concluded that the Board needed to determine whether the applicant had met its burden of proof by demonstrating the hardships supporting the C1 variances and showing that the benefits of the C2 variances outweighed any substantial detriments. 28
PUBLIC QUESTIONS - Mr. Joseph Panullo asked Mr. Moronski whether any portion of the retaining wall running along Eagle Rock Avenue would extend into the driveway on either side of the country club's ingress and egress. Mr. Moronski initially stated that the retaining wall along Eagle Rock Avenue would not extend into the driveway. - Mr. Panullo asked whether that meant the driveway grade would have no walls on either side and would consist.only' of natural landscaping. Mr. Moronski clarified that he had been referring to the wall:along Eagle Rock Avenue. He explained that although the frontage wall would not turn into the driveway at the intersection, the plans did show retaining walls farther along the driveway itself. -» Mr. Panullo asked whether the wall would make a 90-degree turn from Eagle Rock Avenue’ into the country club property. Mr. Moronski stated that it would not. vate ‘Mr. Panullo asked whether Mr. Moronski could estimate the survival rate of the replacement trees, such as whether 100% or 80% could be expected to survive. Mr. Moronskistated'that tree survivability in those soil conditions was not within his area of expertise because he was not a landscape architect. | «Mr! Kevin Malanga of Ridgé Road asked Mr. Moronski whether he had testified that the proposediimprovements would not increase the intensity of use of the country club. Mr. le Moronski ‘confirmed that statement as it related to the proposed improvements. He explained that the country club was a permitted use and that the improvements themsélves. would not contribute to an increase in the intensity of use. ~> Mr. Malanga asked! what necessitated increasing the size of the parking lot. Mr. Moronski v stated that the propetty:was technically deficient in the number of required parking spaces. He explained that the proposed improvements would create a more efficient ‘parking loivayout, resulting in additional spaces and reducing the existing nonconforming condition. =| /Mr. Malanga asked what-changes in operations required the additional parking spaces. Mr. Moronski explained that, from his perspective as a planner, the proposed layout »would provide a more orderly and efficient arrangement of parking spaces and that increasing the number of spaces was an overall benefit. ~)'MroMalanga asked whether Crestmont Country Club could continue operating without | tbo the
efficient arrangement of parking spaces and that increasing the number of spaces was an overall benefit. ~)'MroMalanga asked whether Crestmont Country Club could continue operating without | tbo the additional 36 parking spaces. Mr. Moronski stated that he did not believe the question ‘was relevant to his planning analysis. He explained that the additional spaces would improve the:existing nonconforming parking condition and that he considered the increase a positive contribution to the overall site design. - Mr. Malanga referred to Mr. Moronski's testimony concerning the aesthetic benefits of the project and asked how the proposed improvements would benefit the general public. - Mr. Moronski stated that the project included both aesthetic and functional benefits. He identified the proposed landscaping and tree planting along Eagle Rock Avenue, together with the roadway and circulation improvements. - Mr. Malanga asked what aesthetic benefit members of the public who did not belong to Crestmont Country Club would receive from removing trees along Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Moronski stated that trees would also be added along Eagle Rock Avenue and that the improvements to the frontage would accompany the roadway improvements. He reiterated that the project was not exclusively aesthetic but also provided functional circulation benefits. - Mr. Malanga asked how the circulation improvements would benefit people who were not members of the country club. Mr. Moronski responded that nonmembers of the country club also drive on Eagle Rock Avenue. 29
- Mr. Malanga asked specifically how cutting down trees along Eagle Rock Avenue would improve circulation. Mr. Moronski stated that the trees being removed would be replaced in accordance with the Township's tree replacement requirements and that the applicant was complying with those requirements. - Mr. Malanga asked whether it was correct that 313 trees were being removed to provide 36 additional parking spaces for a private country club. Mr. Moronski responded that the trees being removed would be replaced with more than 500 trees, as described in the earlier testimony. He emphasized that the application involved more than additional parking ‘spaces and included improvements providing benefits to the public as well as to the applicant. - | MrMalanga'repeated his question concerning whether 313 trees were being removed to provide 36 additional parking spaces. Mr. Moronski disagreed with that characterization and stated that the trée removal was not solely attributable to the additional parking spaces. + > Mr. Malangalasked how many trees would be removed solely for the additional 36 parking spaces: MrsMoronski stated that the testimony had extensively addressed the total number of trees being rerhoved and replaced as part of the overall project. He stated that he did:notibelieve separating the tree removal by the additional parking spaces was televant.because.the application included more than the parking expansion. ~0-Mr.:Malanga continued»dsking whether Mr. Moronski knew the specific number of trees being removed solely for the parking spaces. Mr. Moronski stated that he had provided ithe informatjon-available to him and referred to the testimony already presented regarding the overall project. ~) Mr. Malanga asked what documentary evidence Mr. Moronski or any member of Langan Engineering ‘had; demonstrated that Essex County was in favor of installing the proposed traffic signal. Mr. Schkolnick objected to the question. Mr. Moronski stated he was not involved in any of the meetings with the County +. Mr. Malanga.asked whether it is Mr. Morinski’s testimony that a private entity was \ bearing the expense of this project. Mr. Moronski stated that he did not say a private entity was bearing the expense of this project. Instead, a private entity is working with the County to help further this project -<Mr. Malanga asked who the private entity is.
did not say a private entity was bearing the expense of this project. Instead, a private entity is working with the County to help further this project -<Mr. Malanga asked who the private entity is. Mr. Morinski stated the applicant is working with the County with regards to the improvements to their property - Mr. Malaniga asked whether there are any other entities involved in the expense of this .oyproject.:Mr. Morinski stated he is only involved in this application and does not know whether there are other entities involved in the expense BOARD RECOMMENDATIONS - Chairman Bagoff recommended that a condition be included requiring the applicant to maintain the proposed sidewalk along Eagle Rock Avenue. He specified that maintenance should include snow removal, repairs, and removal of any greenery or foliage that could obstruct the sidewalk and prevent pedestrians from safely using it. o Ms. McGovern stated that the proposed condition was consistent with case law, referencing Christmas v. City of Newark, which establishes a duty for commercial property owners to maintain their sidewalks. She confirmed that she would include sidewalk maintenance as a condition. The application will be carried to the next planning board regular meeting on October 7, 2026, without further notice at 7:30 P.M. 30
e PB-26-02 Catalyst Development Group, LLC 27 Fairway Drive Block: 86.01 Lot: 6 Zone: R-5 The applicant is requesting preliminary and final minor subdivision approval, with “c” variance relief, to subdivide the property into 3 lots. The application will be carried to the next planning board regular meeting on October 7, 2026, without further notice at 7:30 P.M. e PB-26-01 15 Ridgeway LLC 15 Ridgeway LLC Block: 158 Lot: 28.01 Zone: R4 The applicants seeking a minor subdivision with bulk variance approval to create an additional building lot from an oversized lot. The application will be carried to/the next planning board regular meeting on October 7, 2026, without further notice at 7:30 P.M. apopren: 1/4/26 Jaque Jamilet Baqueri#¥ Vite 2oard: Secretary Planning Board’Secretary 31
File revisions (1)
- Nov 6, 2026
c1f7e551165725,244,207 bytes