Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Dec 2, 2026

Crestmont_July_1_2026_Condensed_with_Keyword_Index

Preserved file SHA-2566b01a07575178f40ccc1c7fd2bb7800eee739e10fe0f22bab1042ebe5cb03c5a

Indexed text

Page 37

again, all of these measures, the retention basins, the porous pavement, and -- and everything else that’s been tied together is to achieve compliance with your current stormwater regulations. So then what I’m going to talk about here is the tree count and the tree removal and replacement. So I’m now switching to the partial tree removal plan, and what that does is identifies trees that are within the limit of the disturbance that are -- are -- that are basically being removed and then the -- using the town’s calculations for replacement based upon the diameters of the existing trees, the condition is we’re1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 141 removing 313 trees. And as a function of the replacement ratios that are required by the town by the ordinance, we’re going to be putting back a total of 486 trees. Now, I’m going to modify that by 11 the way this plan refers to the 400 -- 586 trees to address a comment from your engineer that the 11 or (indiscernible) planner. I apologize. That the 11 trees we counted for compliance with your landscape in parking lot requirements, we’re going to not take credit for those as replacement trees, we’re going to add 11 more trees. So this will be a count of 597 trees for the purpose of the replacement trees. Q So John, what -- A Those trees -- Q John, what -- what sheet are we on? And -- A So I am on -- I’m on -- I apologize. I’m on the partial tree removal plan, which is LD-101. Q Okay. And you’re making a -- an oral amendment here to basically saying we’ll comply with the -- A To address the comment. Yeah. Q Just, you’ll comply with the review letter and add -- A That’s correct. Q -- 11 more trees because of the -- the way1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 142 the calculation was done. We’re -- we’re happy to add the 11 additional to the 586 -- A Correct. Q -- already. A Correct. Q Okay. A And then, you know, again, based on the ratios, we’re at the 586 but in particular, the way the trees are being replaced, we have them in a combination of locations on the site. So there’s a summary table on the plan identifying the 586 trees and the placement relative to the areas where we’re doing our bulk improvements up along Eagle Rock Ave and Laurel and the parking areas that are being reconfigured as well as then on the whole -- Crestmont

Page 37

e placement relative to the areas where we’re doing our bulk improvements up along Eagle Rock Ave and Laurel and the parking areas that are being reconfigured as well as then on the whole -- Crestmont property as a whole. So 303 trees will be placed along that frontage area and an addition 239 trees will be placed on the overall Crestmont property. And then to get to the full count, we had proposed 44 trees off-site in coordination with your forester for the -- to hit the 586. But that 44, to the -- to an amend -- oral amendment of this plan, will become 55 to get the additional 11 trees that we proposed. So we’ll have a total of the 597 trees to be planted as associated with this application. So what I’ll do now is I’m going to talk a little

Page 38

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 143 bit about the location where the trees are being taken out are based on the limits of disturbance of the property. And one of the questions about why are the walls being proposed in the steep slope areas is that by going with the wall configuration -- have the grading, we’d have been able to minimize the trees that need to come out. Had we eliminated and not done walls along either Eagle Rock or at the base elevation of the upper level parking enhancements and increased parking, it would have required more of these trees that you see un-X-ed out here would have had to been taken out as a function of the -- the grading. So the walls serve two purposes: one, to consolidate the development limits to minimize disturbance, but also to eliminate removal of additional trees. So looking at, then -- I’m going to advance to the planting plans, I’ll -- I’ll show the second sheet, I’m sorry, first -- west -- easterly sheet. And in a similar fashion, the easterly sheet, the trees that are being removed are being removed associated with the disturbances in the areas and anything, you know, from a -- outside the limit of disturbance will be subject to tree protection measures that are consistent with your forester’s and your -- your ordinance requirements.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 144 So, now, looking at the planting plan and looking at what’s proposed there, so for the total number of trees that are being placed on the site as a whole, the 303 trees that are proposed along the frontage area, I’ll call it that, the northerly portion where the predominant improvements are being proposed, they’re a combination of different types of trees. I’m not going to speak to the -- the actual species of the trees, but rather -- I’ll -- the plans refer to those but also we are going to make substitutions in accordance with the review comments we got. There’s a request in the review comments to make various substitutions, so the plan will be consistent with those comments as a function of, you know, complying with the -- the comments provided to us. But a combination of shade trees, ornamental trees are the predominant, those are the trees being used for the replacement. There’s also additional to that the deciduous trees -- I’m sorry, the evergreen

Page 38

a combination of shade trees, ornamental trees are the predominant, those are the trees being used for the replacement. There’s also additional to that the deciduous trees -- I’m sorry, the evergreen trees, excuse me. That’ll be part of that planting as well as shrubs, both evergreen and deciduous shrubs, ornamental grasses, ground covers, and perennials. So there’s a substantial planting program here, and what I referred to a little bit earlier is we are going to be planting the -- the small-scale bio- retention basin and that’ll be compliant with DEP1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 145 standards. Now, the trees -- the 40 trees that are going to be planted in there are going to be what they refer to as whips. They don’t count towards your restoration, or towards -- we don’t -- we -- they’re not a -- a number to offset our trees removed and trees restored, but they will grow to become additional trees here that you may not see initially as substantial, but this should be a substantial feature of additional trees as they grow over time. So the -- the planting scenario also allows for what’ll look like somewhat of a streetscape along Eagle Rock Ave. Right now, if you were to look at the existing trees, they’re one, in -- in various states of -- various conditions, but there’s also a lot of scrub and a lot of other growth there that is on an embankment slope. So, what we’re going to do is basically clean that up to create this area that we talked about before, allow for the wall to be imposed along that area to allow for those grades to be pulled back, and then along the lines of the area adjacent to Eagle Rock, there’ll be a significant replacement filling in those areas where trees were removed but now are being replaced by the new trees. And in a similar fashion, on the east end of the site, we’re doing a very similar scenario along Eagle1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 146 Rock Avenue. And then within the islands that get reconfigured associated with the existing parking, the lower level. So, again, this is -- you know, should present, you know, in terms of being an extensive planting scenario. And then with that, we’re also planting elsewhere in the site to get the tree count for the property as a whole to hit that higher number minus the 55 that’ll be proposed

Page 38

extensive planting scenario. And then with that, we’re also planting elsewhere in the site to get the tree count for the property as a whole to hit that higher number minus the 55 that’ll be proposed off-site. So what I’m going to refer to is I’ll get -- turn to the -- in this particular case, to the tree restoration plans. These, again, are drawings that are in the set. The drawings are titled -- sorry, in the submitted sets. The tree restoration plan is LP-201 and the tree restoration plan shows the big picture of where the additional areas, areas A through H throughout the site. And these were coordinated with the golf course operations folks to basically walk the entire site and come up with areas where additional trees can be planted, don’t interfere with the golf operations or the golf experience itself but allow for a supplemental tree plantings around those areas to fill in, if you want to say, blanks, or areas that have an opportunity for additional trees. So, again, these areas span from both -- both the northerly Eagle Rock Ave location all the way to the southern portion of the site and making your way around

Page 39

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 147 all -- the property that’s within the West Orange limits of the property. So, looking back, then, at the plant set, the other elements we’re adding to this are lighting. The lighting plans, this is LL-101, which is the partial lighting plan associated with the westerly portion of the site. We’re providing fixtures in the new parking lot area and we’re also providing fixtures along Eagle Rock Avenue. There were comments in the letters asking about the two different mounting heights. On-site, we’re using the 18-foot, or ordinance mounting height. Off-site, we’re working with the existing layout of the holes that are out there now, and they operate at a 27- foot height. And the -- those are the standard -- they’re referred to as cobra head-type lights. That’ll be lighting the county. And that’s -- that will be within the county’s jurisdiction, so we’re not proposing 27-foot high on the property. So we don’t see that as a variance, because it’s going to be under the county’s jurisdiction. But we want to make note of why there’s a differential between the two different heights. Another item noted, and I’m going to go to the easterly drawing now. This is LL-102. In a similar fashion, we’re providing lighting in the upper parking lot area down the access drive. When we get to the end1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 148 of the access drive, there’s a note about a potential variance about a foot-candle intensity of 3.5 at the property line where the driveway comes out. We’re lighting the driveway for purposes of the county’s review, so I don’t know, if it’s considered a variance, if it would be under county’s jurisdiction for the purpose of the lighting. But if it is, you know, then we would ask for that variance to be granted associated with it being to comply with the off-site roadway design requirements for the lighting along Eagle Rock Avenue. Otherwise, the light fixtures are -- I’m going to refer down to the detail sheet. This is sheet LL-501. They’ll -- they’re the -- what they refer to as the pedestrian post-mount op -- sorry, post-top pedestrian lights. Are basically fixture heads mounted at the 18- foot mounting height. That’s per the ordinance. And then out on the street, on Eagle Rock Avenue, they’ll have the -- excuse me, the

Page 39

p pedestrian lights. Are basically fixture heads mounted at the 18- foot mounting height. That’s per the ordinance. And then out on the street, on Eagle Rock Avenue, they’ll have the -- excuse me, the cobra head light, which -- people may be familiar -- familiar with. They’re similar to what’s out there now along Eagle Rock Avenue. So, you know, looking at it from the -- the big picture, go back -- excuse me, I apologize, to the overall site and the variances that we’re asking for, I’m just going to renumerate (sic) them, if you don’t1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 149 mind, just to put it on record. I’m going to go back to the initial plan for the site plan. So we have the variance from section 25-12.1.b, the minimum distance from parking area to fencing, screening, or structure. Again, that occurs in proximity to the modular structure that was recently constructed and we’re using that as a protective measure for the allowing still the pedestrian access adjacent to that modular building. The second variance, or next variance was the minimum number of parking spaces. We -- where 700 is required. We’re -- we’re reducing the current variance from 252 spaces to 292 spaces, and that’s associated with the testimony provided by -- by the -- for the operations to say that the additional parking is associated with changes the way the facility’s been utilized in recent times. The next variance is the -- section 25-28.8.f.11, the maximum retaining wall height of feet. We’re proposing 21.2 -- 21.5 feet, excuse me. And again, that’s specifically related to the area where we are combining the upper lot improvements and in contrast to the lower level retention basin that we need, or retention -- small-scale bio-retention basin needed to hit the water quality and water quantity requirements for stormwater management. So that area is basically1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 150 where that occurs. Then, looking at the variance request for the -- related to the steep slopes, so a lot of what I spoke about earlier is reflected in the steep slopes exhibits that are provided in the plan set. This is actually the partial steep slope analysis with site plan overlay drawing, EX-04. What EX-04 identifies is the various areas on the site, and the -- and the extent of the slopes

Page 39

n the plan set. This is actually the partial steep slope analysis with site plan overlay drawing, EX-04. What EX-04 identifies is the various areas on the site, and the -- and the extent of the slopes within those areas. So the -- Q John? John, hold on one second. We didn’t submit that colorized, did we? A Yes, we did. Q We did -- our plan set has it colorized? A Yeah. Yeah. Q Okay. A That’s -- that’s correct. Yes. So -- so, looking at that from an overall -- you know, the big picture is that this end of the site, in order to make your way from where we’re starting with at the upper level parking lot and lower level parking lot out to Eagle Rock Avenue, there’s a transition in topography to get down to Eagle Rock Avenue. Those -- those elevations I was talking about before in that 20- to 30-foot range of changing grade over portions of the site. So, in order to minimize some of the disturbances,

Page 40

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 151 like the example I was referring to earlier, we are imposing a wall along this portion of where the steep slopes are for the -- in order to minimize that disturbance. These walls, for the purpose of, you know, record, will become -- you know, they’ll be designed and have to be approved by the building department for the purpose of construction of the walls so the -- the idea behind this is that they’ll -- there’ll be a -- the safety factor associated with the walls is built into that design and that would have to be, again, reviewed by the building department as a function of the -- the construction. So we have a second level of -- of review on that as that -- that comes to bear if this project were to be approved. Additionally, transitioning from the upper level parking lot down to the lower level parking lot, we have an area where we’re traversing that slope, so in or der to smooth that slope out to make it a drivable en -- exit maneuver, we have to put the walls as well as the roadway through, again, portions of the steep slopes to make -- to allow for that exit maneuver. And then on a similar note, along Eagle Rock Ave, the area that we are leveling off is that steeper slope that you see out there today from where the curb line is out to the top of the slope, pulling that back and1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 152 imposing a retaining wall along the length of that in order to create the safe -- I can’t think of the right term for it, but the safe zone from the curb line to the -- to the -- where the wall is proposed. I may not be using the right term, but Karl Pehnke’s description earlier about that more leveled-off area adjacent to the roadway is -- is part of the technical design for the -- for compliance for the county’s purpose. So from a steep slopes point of view, you know, the .38 acres that we’re disturbing associated with the total of the 3.8 acre areas that are 25 percent or greater are, again, associated with minimizing disturbance, allowing the roadway access to make its way through and allow for the proper design of the off- site roadway, Eagle Rock Avenue. The last item we had was the maximum driveway slope, section 25-28.8.f.8 where six percent is allowed and we’re proposing a combination of both eight and

Page 40

n of the off- site roadway, Eagle Rock Avenue. The last item we had was the maximum driveway slope, section 25-28.8.f.8 where six percent is allowed and we’re proposing a combination of both eight and a half and ten and a half. The ten and a half is the existing condition that’s there today and the eight and a half is along our main driveway. And again, the -- the difficulty on this si te was to connect the grades at a county-compliant access point to Eagle Rock Avenue with grades in the ranges going from the five percent coming off of this intersection through to eight and a half percent back1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Cote - Direct 153 to the grades that tie into the upper level parking, and that’s what creates the condition for the eight and a half percent. And again, the ten and a half is existing. The section 25-14.1, the lighting I spoke to earlier, if that is a variance, we will request that, again, if -- if necessary, again, providing safety for both vehicular and pedestrian movements through the intersection. We do also have requests for a site plan waiver regarding the removal of trees on the 10 percent slopes or greater. If you look at this plan, there’s a significant amount of 10 percent slopes throughout the area, so those trees, again, are not only -- they’re being removed, but they’re also then being replaced with the multiplier that the town has for the restoration component of it. So, again, it’s associated with the grading needed from Eagle Rock Avenue even, again, trying to minimize grades and impacts associated with the new parking lot and the driveways. So those trees being removed in those areas are -- are associated with the -- again, trying to minimize those for where we need to put the various improvements in. So, I believe that’s the heart of my testimony. I1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 154 wanted to keep it concise. If there’s any questions from there or any additional information I need to provide, I’m, you know, happy to provide any additional content. MR. SCHKOLNICK: Are you anticipating any questions, Mr. Cote? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: At this hour, Mr. Cote, Mr. Schkolnick, we’re going to carry this and the board will ask questions the next time. I recommend we carry this to the September 2nd regular planning board meeting at 6:30 p.m. via Zoom. Will

File revisions (1)